Lukewarm Reaction to NY Imam on Middle East Tour


Dubai : A heated US debate over a planned Islamic centre near New York’s World Trade Center site is seen by Middle East media, scholars and citizens as more of a domestic American issue rather than an attack on their faith.

Kuwait-born Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, the Muslim cleric leading the project to establish the centre, has been in Bahrain, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates in the past two weeks but met with a more subdued reaction than the US media.

“Muslims this time are not part of this, they didn’t call for it, they didn’t defend it and didn’t bother with the whole issue,” Saudi columnist, Abdulrahman al-Rashid, wrote in the pan-Arab daily Asharq Alawsat.

The US row is perceived as much less of an affront to Islam than Switzerland’s vote to ban minarets and France’s moves to forbid the full face veil, observers say.

Asked whether the American people were becoming more intolerant, the Imam Abdul Rauf played down American prejudice. “If they are informed properly about what the actual facts of the situation are, they will always make the right decision,” he said.

Abdul Rauf’s project, now named Park51, has been dubbed by its critics the “Ground Zero Mosque” because of its proximity to the World Trade Centre site where nearly 3,000 people were killed in the Sept. 11 attacks.

Families of victims of Sept. 11 and conservative politicians have mounted an emotional campaign to block the planned centre, saying its location was a provocation.

An American Muslim cleric who delivers a weekly sermon at an Abu Dhabi mosque said the row was more about US domestic politics with the Nov. 2 congressional vote looming.

“It’s really a local issue,” the cleric, Jihad Hashim Brown, said. “It has to do with the current congressional election. As soon as the elections are finished it will blow over.”

Recent French moves to ban Muslim women from wearing the niqab or burqa in public triggered more of a media outcry in the Middle East.

“The niqab ban was a state-endorsed one and so seemed to Muslims like an act of oppression,” said public relations consultant Riham el Houshi, 22, an Egyptian living in Qatar, adding that she thought building the planned center was insensitive.

Qatari Ghanim al-Naimi said the right to build mosques anywhere in the world should be guaranteed: “Religion had nothing to do with (Sept. 11).”


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
2004 . All Rights Reserved.