By  Mowahid Hussain Shah

May 14 , 2010

Strategic Folly

 

The arrest of a suspect on attempted terror-bombing charges in Times Square, New York, has sharply escalated Pakistani-specific pressures in the US. Bluntness has replaced politeness.

Some gaps are revealed in two key prongs of the existing strategy. First, is over-reliance on a violent mode. Second, is over-reliance on the favored ‘moderate’ Muslim ruling classes. Neither approach is really working. Both, in fact, have actually fueled the fires and furies of militancy.

Common to both the West and the Muslim world is one key factor: elements of the Muslim youth, either in the West or residing in their own homelands who are, in a sense, marginalized, frustrated, and excluded. They don’t have a sense of ownership of their environment nor do they have a place at the table. Their lack of belonging and sense of social insignificance make them prone to nefarious exploitation.

The thievery of the Muslim ruling classes adds to the Robin Hood lure of militancy.

Within Muslim societies, the moment is ripe to accurately identify and rectify what is wrong. The ruling classes have conclusively demonstrated that they neither have the learning nor the yearning to grapple with the size and scope of the challenge.

Policies have been rushed through without being mindful of their repercussions. Within the US, they have helped instill and spread a culture of irrational fear and false alarm. The focus on short-term tactical benefits has created long-term strategic burdens.

It has not been adequately weighed that the upsurge in militancy is one byproduct of the intensity of US military engagements in the Muslim world, which additionally assists in providing a theological justification for the militant narrative.

A common refrain permeates the militant narrative: the Palestinian problem and the Kashmir conflict. Yet, this issue is being swallowed without a serious diagnosis.

Thus far, the US has failed to meet the militant ideology with a persuasive counter-ideology. Without fairness and consistency, the management of such message is difficult. The pitting of the Christian West against the Muslim East is a mutually ruinous rift which only seeks to benefit those who would profit from it by witnessing this tamasha.

 

Instructive here are the examples of Egypt and Pakistan. Both countries are technically allies of the United States. Both are pivotal in the Muslim world. Both setups are attempting to perpetuate a dynastic order. And both have become a cradle for militancy. The masses of both these countries harbor deep disquiet over US intentions. By relying on ruling elites, the US is only ending up with false friends and genuine foes. The present-day ruling clique bears close resemblance to the moral decay of the Whitehall-backed King Farouk’s rule 60 years ago in Egypt when praetorian shadows were lengthening.

Washington ’s trend to seek conformity and compliance in the Muslim world has produced sycophants but not friends. The short-cut American penchant for “let’s-make-a-deal” with parasitic local elites is not working.

The voices of sanity and serenity need to be equally weighed. The West has not fully examined the heavy toll that wars in the Middle East have taken on Muslim psyche and self-esteem.

One key lesson of the post-9/11 era is that the destinies of the Western world and the Muslim world are interwoven. Therefore, each episode of attempted or executed terror is also an opportune moment for more comprehension and outreach. It would be prudent to brace for more such episodes. They will not be deterred by more screening at airports or by more xenophobic scrutiny of Muslims in the West. The strategic folly of doing more of the same needs to be re-examined.

 


PREVIOUSLY


Clash or Coexistence?

The Radical Behind Reconstruction

POWs & Victors’ Justice

Islam on Campus

Community of Civilizations

Rule of Law or Rule of Men?

Unpredictable Times

The Quiet One

Turkish Model & Principled Resignations

Live and Let Live

Leadership & de Gaulle

Dark Side of Power

2002: The Year of Escalation

Whither US?

Politics, God, Cricket & Sex

The Company of Friends

Missing in Action : The Kofi Case

Accountability & Anger

Casualties of War

A Simple Living

The Nexus & Muslim Nationhood

The Kith and Kin Culture

It Is Spreading

Road to Nowhere

Misrepresenting Muslims

The value of curiosity

Revenge & Riches

The Media on Iraq

The Perils of Sycophancy

Legends of Punjab

Mind & Muscle

Islam & the West: Conflict or Co-Existence?

The Challenge of Disinformation

Britain on the Backfoot

Paisa, Power and Privilege

The Path to Peace

On Intervention

Countering Pressures on Pakistan

A World at War?

Raising the Game

The Argument of Force

Affluence withtout Influence

The Shawdow of Vietnam

Heroes of '54

The Imperative of Human Decency

Hollywood and Hate

Living in Lahore

Fatal Decisions

Singer or the Song

Arrogance

The Power of Moral Legitimacy

The Trouble with Kerry

Green Curtain

A Nation Divided

Election 2004: Decisive but Divisive

Muslim Youth & Kashmir in America

The Big Picture: Wealth without Vision

Oxygen to Global Unrest

Punishing the Punctual

Change without Change

Don’t Be Weak

Passionate Attachment

The Confidence of Youth

The Other Side of Democracy

Campaign of Defamation

Pakistani Women & the Legal Profession

A Pakistani Journey

Farewell to Fazal

Mukhtaran and Beyond

Revamping the OIC

7/7 & After

Nuclear Double-Standard

Return to Racism

Hollywood – The Unofficial Media

The Sole Superpower

The UN at 60

A Slow Motion World War?

Elite vs. Street

Iqbal Today

Macedonia to Multan

Defending our Own

2006 & Maulana Zafar Ali Khan

Error against Terror

The Limits of Power

Cultural Weaknesses

Aggressive at Home, Submissive Abroad

Global Storm

The Farce of Free Expression

The Changing Mood

Condi & India

Xenophobia

Looking inward

Re-Thinking

A Tale of Two Presidents

Close to Home

Flashpoint Kashmir

The Spreading Rage

Confronting Adversity

The Illusion of International Law

Other Side of Extremism

Five Years after 9/11

The Educated Ignorant

The Decline of Humor

Icons

Six Years of Insanity

The War Not Being Fought

Munir Niazi

Compliance & Defiance

Counter-Message

Miscast

The Goddess of Wealth

The Meaning of Moderation

The Tora Bora of Fear

Clash of Civility

The Early Race

Challenge & Response

Will & Skill

Zealotry

Movie-Media and Pakistan

Hug with a Thug

Quest for Integrity

Unconquered

Vanity

Bringing Back the Past

Stuck in Iraq

Islam, Science and the West

Turmoil over Turkey

Leaders versus Leadership

Might Does Not Make Right

Kursi First

Vision & Will

Battle of the Billionaires

Assassination Alley

Extremism and Change

Rosy Expectations

Short-Term Gain, Long-Term Pain

Not Winning

Beyond Baghdad: Five Years after

The Hijab of Democracy

Hate, Fear & Hope

Weapon of Words

Hide N’ Seek

Yanking in the UN

Obama’s Breakthrough

Let Lahore Be Lahore

National Mood & Sports

Flirting with Fire

Trips Abroad

Georgia on the Mind

Duel for the White House

Zia to Zardari

Palestine: Avoiding the Unavoidable 

Not Working 

In the Ring 

Obama’s America

Smiles & Dreams

Quiet Deeds of Good

Crime and Indifference

Journey of Understanding

VIP-hunting

Terror via Counter-Terrorism

Umpires or Vampires?

The Long Road

Yesterday’s Reminder

Appeasement and the Real Threat

Israel’s Washington Agenda

New Challenges

Cairo and Beyond

Re-fighting Old Battles

America ’s Super Villains

Activism in America

Style without Substance

Overcoming Barriers

Ashes to Afghanistan

The Looming Change

Fear and Possibilities

What Is Not Debated 

Hired Guns

Rampage at Fort Hood

Manmohan in Washington

The Long Duel

Green Nukes

Vision and Division

Avoiding Why

Striving to Matter

Shame-proof

Anxiety and Opportunity

Putting Iraq in America

The Right Strategy

Looking Beyond

Rot at the Top


2001

 

Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 pakistanlink.com . All Rights Reserved.