By Dr Muzammil H. Siddiqi

Can Muslims Be Good Americans?


A Muslim brother forwarded to me the following email written by an anonymous Christian. It seems that the email is being sent all over to create hate and misunderstanding about Islam and Muslims. Following are my answers in brief to the questions asked.
This is very interesting and we all need to read it from start to finish. And send it on to everyone. Maybe this is why our American Muslims are so quiet and not speaking out about any atrocities.

Answer: Muslims individually and collectively have spoken against the terrorists. Muslim Americans are law-abiding citizens and have opposed any act of violence and terrorism. You should read the Fatwa of The Fiqh Council of North America against Terrorism available at

Question: Can a good Muslim be a good American?

Answer: Yes, Muslim can and millions of Muslims are good American citizens. They are living here with their families and children and wish peace and prosperity for all. They are doctors, engineers, teachers, lawyers, professionals and common folks. They wish nothing but good for America and for all its people.
Question: This question was forwarded to a friend who worked in Saudi Arabia for 20 years. The following is his reply:
Answer: Sadly, this person did not learn much about Islam. His answers are full of ignorance and hate.
Question: Theologically - no. Because his allegiance is to Allah, The moon God of Arabia.

Answer: Allah is the Arabic word for God. Arabi- speaking Christians also say, ‘Allah’ when they speak about God. One can check any Arabic Bible, it has the name Allah on almost every page.  Muslims’ allegiance is to Allah who is the Universal God, the same God recognized by Jews and Christians and all monotheists.

Allah is not the moon god. Allah is the creator of sun and moon and the whole universe. It is totally false to claim that Muslims worship moon. Muslims worship One and Universal God, Allah.
Question: Religiously – no. Because no other religion is accepted by His Allah  except Islam ( Qur’an, 2:256)(Koran)

Answer: Muslims believe that Islam is the true religion.  Christians believe that Christianity is the true religion and they say that ‘no one can be saved unless he/she believes in Jesus as the Son of God.’ Jews believe that Judaism is the true religion.  An American does not have to be a Christian. In this country every person has a right to believe in his/her religion. So a Muslim could be as good American as a Christian, Jew, Hindu, Buddhist, theist or atheist could be. There is no provision in the American Constitution that says that only Christians can be Americans.
Question: Scripturally - no. Because his allegiance is to the five Pillars of Islam and the Qur’an.

Answer: Five Pillars are our act of worship and Qur’an is our Scripture. Jews have their Scripture and their ways of worship and Christians have theirs. Jews and Christians have many denominations and groups. No one says that only one group’s scripture and worship is American and others’ way of worship is not American. It seems to me that the person does not understand the American system.
Question: Geographically – no. Because his allegiance is to Mecca , to which he turns in prayer five times a day.

Answer: Makkah, Madinah and Jerusalem are our holy cities and we respect them and honor them. We worship towards the direction of Makkah. Jews turn to Jerusalem in their prayers. Every person is free in America to worship the way they like. Why one way is American and the other way is not?
Question: Socially - no. Because his allegiance to Islam forbids him to make friends with Christians or Jews.

Answer: Muslims are not only allowed, they are urged to be friendly towards all people. The Qur’an says that ‘God does not forbid you to be kind and benevolent towards those who do not fight you because of your religion and do not expel you from your homes… (See Surah 60:7) We have many Jewish and Christian friends and we care for them and respect them.
Question: Politically – no. Because he must submit to the mullahs ( spiritual leaders), who teach annihilation of Israel and destruction of America , the great Satan.

Answer: There are all kinds of Mullas and all kind of priests and rabbis. Not all Muslims are supposed to follow all Mullas or to accept everything that every Mulla says. It is like saying that a Catholic cannot be trusted because some of their priests were involved in sex scandals.
Question: Domestically - no. Because he is instructed to marry four women and beat/scourge his wife when she disobeys him (Qur’an 4:34 )

Answer: No Muslim is instructed to marry four women. Marrying four wives is not a duty of Muslims and among them there are very few who practice this all over the world. Muslims are allowed to have more than one wife, on the condition that they must treat them equally and fairly. However, if they live in a country where polygamy is forbidden by the law, they must respect that law, because in this situation if they have more than one wife they shall not be able to treat all their wives equally. They will declare one legal wife and they shall hide the other wife’s identity. This is not fair and equal treatment.

Islam teaches respect of women and love and kindness between spouses (Surah 30:21). The writer misunderstood the verse 4:34. The Prophet – peace be upon him - gave the best explanation when he said, “The best of you are those who do not hit their wives.’ The objective of the Qur’an is to save families, not to destroy them with abuse and violence.

The Bible says that parents should have their children stoned to death if they are stubborn or rebellious. (Deut 21:16-21; Exodus 21:15-17; Leviticus 20:9) Does it mean that Jews and Christians cannot be trusted as good parents and good Americans?

Question: Intellectually - no. Because he cannot accept the American
Constitution since it is based on Biblical principles and he believes the Bible to be corrupt.

Answer: There is nothing in the American Constitution that is against the teachings of Islam. Whatever Biblical principles are incorporated in the US Constitution are also Islamic. The Qur’an and the Bible have many common teachings.
Question: Philosophically - no. Because Islam, Muhammad, and the Qur’an do not allow freedom of religion and expression. Democracy and Islam cannot co-exist.  Every Muslim government is either dictatorial or autocratic.

Answer: Islam gives full freedom of religion and full freedom of expression within the limits of decency and morality. It is not correct that every Muslim government is either dictatorial or autocratic. Muslims have recovered from Western colonialism recently and they are struggling to establish their democratic governments. Governments like Turkey, Malaysia, Indonesia and many others have succeeded very much in establishing democratic system in their lands.
Question: Spiritually - no. Because when we declare 'one nation under God,' the Christians’ God is loving and kind, while Allah is NEVER referred to as heavenly father, nor is he ever called love in the Qur’an's 99 excellent names.

Answer: In the Qur’an God is called ‘Wadud’ which means the most Loving one. We believe in the Loving and Merciful God. The most repeated names of God in the Qur’an are ‘al-Rahman and al-Rahim, meaning the most Merciful, the Most Compassionate. Compassion and mercy are more comprehensive than love.
Question: Therefore, after much study and deliberation.... Perhaps we should be very suspicious of ALL MUSLIMS in this country. - - - They obviously cannot be both 'good' Muslims and good Americans. Call it what you wish it's still the truth. You had better believe it. The more we understand this, the better it will be for our country and our future.

Answer: This is only bigoted propaganda. For centuries some Christians had similar propaganda against Jews. Now they have started this against Muslims, because they know that anti-Semitism is illegal in this country. Unfortunately, Muslims have become an easy target for some people.
Question: The religious war is bigger than we know or understand.

Answer: We should not have religious war. Religions should teach peace and respect of each other. Religious people should not bear ‘false witness’ and should love their neighbors.
Question: Footnote: The Muslims have said they will destroy us from within.

Answer: You should not generalize the statement of one or two persons as the statement of all Muslims. We condemn those who excite hate, war and violence. There are some Christians who said that they would burn the Qur’an and destroy Makkah and Madinah. We condemn them, but we do not blame all Christians because of the statements of some people among them.

Answer: Agreed.


I doubt that this is written on behalf of all Marines. It may be the opinion of some hateful and angry ones among them. Most of the Marines are honorable people and they serve America and its Constitution. They help in the protection of our country and all its citizens of all faiths and races. We respect them and honor them.
Question: Please don't delete this until you send it on.

Yes, please send it with my answers.


Healing our Brokenness

Islam: The Middle and the Moderate Path

Basic Commitments of Muslims

Is there anti-Semitism in the Qur’an?

The Truth will Succeed

An Islamic Approach to Pluralism

Zakat and Charity - Our Gratitude to Allah

Al-Taqarrub ila Allah- Getting Closer to Allah

I’tikaf: Spiritual Retreat in Ramadan

Al-Istiqamah: Being Straight and Steadfast

Islam is Peace

Islamic Activism

Peace, Harmony and Good Community: Challenges Ahead for the Muslims of America

Does the Qur’an Teach Violence?

Jihad: Its True Meaning and Purpose

Relocating A Mosque

An Islamic Perspective on Stem Cells Research

Issues and Questions

Issues and Questions

Issues and Questions

Issues and Questions

Unity and Diversity

Issues and Questions

Issues and Questions

Courage and Hope: The Spirit of ‘Ashura’

The Spirit of Hijrah

Issues and Questions

Issues and Questions

The Sincere Faith

Zakat and Fasting in Shawwal

Issues and Question

Fasting for Pregnant and Nursing Women

Partition for Women inside the Masjid

Meetings before Marriage, Zakat to a Brother, Zakat to Pay off Business Loan, False Oath on the Quran, Halala

Friday Prayers, Saying Prayers in English, Adhan before Prayers, the Nature of Allah

Return Policy, Salat in a Church, Marriage, Women Praying Salat-ul-Janazah, Husband and Wife Praying Together, Muslim Imam Performing Christian Wedding

Differences Among Madahib, Rules About Migration, Avoiding Nikah Between Two Eids, Reincarnation

Islam: Faith and Civilization

Jallalah, Salat-ul-Jumu'ah, Nationality
Divorce, Selling Haram Things, Prayers, Non-Muslim Females in Masjid
Muslim Woman's Property, Niyyah for Prayers, Muslim Matrimonial Agencies, Muslim Activism
Women in Masjid, Alcohol-Based Perfumes, Divorce, Daughters' Share in Inheritance, Share of Adopted Children in Inheritance
Do Different Faiths Lead to the Same End?
White Gold, Issues of Mahr, False Oath
Quran on Number of Prayers, Husband-Wife Relations, Soyem and Chelum
Burial, Step Offsprings, Wearing T-Shirts in Masjids
Why Does Allah Allow Suffering and Evil in the World?
Opposite Sex Friends, God's Mercy, Praying Incorrectly, Husband's Last Name, Legal Divorce vs. Islamic Divorce
Missed Prayers, Euthanasia, Bank Interest for Charity
Sun Rising from the West, Pre-existence of Prophet Muhammad, Ghusl Janabah
Fate or Free Will, Nature or Nurture
Issues on Marriage and Sexual Relations Outside Marriage
April 21, 2000
Forgiveness in Islam
'Ashura' Fasting and the New Year of Hijrah
Crescent, Seven Heavens, Baptism
Divorce during Pregnancy, Allegorical Verses
Islam: the Way of Perfection
Why does Allah the Lord use the word "We" to refer to Himself?
Dhikr, Idul Adha
Zakat Issues, Concept of Barakah, Praying in Private, the Last Sermon of the Prophet (PBUH)
Praying in a Chair, Muslim Youth, Hajj Issues
Sunnah Mukkadah, Children of Step Parents, Bid'a, Religion's Role in Success in Life, Eid ul Adha

Zakat on 401K and IRA Accounts
Leading the prayer, Reading the Quran without Wudu, Women in Namaz-e-Janaza
The World Must Change
Issues on Zakat, Fitrah

What does Islam offer to humanity?

Zakat and Charity our Gratitude to Allah

Islam: The Middle and Moderate Path

Halal Meat, Praying Together, Leather Jackets, Cheating in Business, Divorce

Zakat and Charity - Our Gratitude to Allah

Ramadan : The month of Virtues and Blessings

Image of Youth in Islam

Our Positive Action Plan

Muslims and Non-Muslims in each other's Funerals

Prophet 'Isa (Jesus)-Peace be upon him: His Place and Honor in Islam

Does the Qur'an Teach Violence

Allah Akbar - Allah is Great

The Real Mission of Syyedna Husain

The New Year of Hijrah

Be Steadfast!

Faith and Trust in Allah

Lessons of History

The Prophetic Ethics: Our Daily Challenge

Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) - Allah's True Prophet

Dialogue of Cultures and Civilizations

The Spiritual Health

Relocating the Mosque

Can Incentives Resolve the Kashmir Conflict?

Gentle Answers to Some Attacks on the Qur'an and Prophet Muhammad

Justice and Compassion: Laws and Ethics in Islam

Ethnic and Racial Harmony: The Islamic Way

The Spititual Growth

How to Welcome the Month of Ramadan?

Zakat and Charity - Our Gratitude to Allah

What kind of fasting is pleasing to Allah?

Muslims and Non-Muslims in each other's funeral

The Glorious Qur'an: How to Benefit from Its Blessings?

Grace and Good Deeds

The Spirit of Eid-ul-Fitr

Purpose of our Life : The Islamic Perspective

Hajj of the Prophet - Peace Be Upon Him

Renting Property to a Liquor Store, Warranties

Marrying in the Family, Prostration, the first Mosque

Following Sunnah, Hijab, Marrying a Non-Muslim Male, Celebrating Halloween

A Week of Sadness: Shameful Killings in Iraq and Pakistan

Hijrah: The Way to Brotherhood

"Grieve Not, Allah is With Us:" The Spirit of Hijrah

Pakistan with Shoes on, Abortion, Satan and Heaven

Abortion, Medical Tests, Marrying Older Women

Protecting Children, Lying Jokingly

Sweepstakes, Children's Money and Palmistry

Prophet Muhammad: Universal Mercy

Prophet Muhammad: Universal Mercy

Prayers with Cosmetics on, Paper Marriages

Green Card Lottery, Chain Letter and Divorce
Credit Cards, Gold Coins, Walimah, Learning Quran in English, Nanjas Clothes

Prophet Muhammad as a Political Leader

Surah al-Tin: Some Reflections

"Infields" and Killing in the Name of Islam

Good Relations

Islamic Names for New Muslims, Mother's Inheritance, Weddings in Muharram

Issues on Numerical Miracles of the Qur'an, Internet Chats between Males and Females

Family Relations in Islam

Unity Among Muslims

Spirit and Witnesses for Marriage

Double Standards: A Woe for Humanity

Recycled Water and Copyrights

Principles and Goals of Development: An Islamic PerspectiveWomen in Janazah Prayers, Husband and Wife Praying Together
The Spirit of Tolerance in Islam
The Holy Qur’an: How to Benefit from Its Blessings
Zakat on Line, Divorce, Mosques and Political

Questions and Answers by By Dr Muzammil H. Siddiqi

Peace, Harmony and Good Community:
Challenges Ahead for the Muslims of America

Thanksgiving in Islam

Business Ethics in Islam

The Way to Success and Salvation:
‘Reflections on Súrah al-‘Aßr

Relocating a Mosque
Praying Jummah Zawal, Selling Pork, Reading the Quran at Same Level
Issues and Questions
Issues and Questions
Reflections on Hajj

Hajj Akbar, Qurbani, Taharah and Zakat
Islamic Names for New Muslims, Mother’s Inheritance
Seven Great Characters
Woman Imam Leading Men and Women in Salat
Questions of Life and Death
Hajj During Íddah, Marriage without Financial Obligations, Urinating in Standing Position

Issues and Questions
Prayers with Pictures in the Room, Madhahib and Unity

Prophet Muhammad as a Humanitarian Leader
Du'a after the Fard Prayers, Fasting in Shawal, Nikah through E-mail
Zakat, Umra, Settlement Money in Car Accidents
Ten Principles of Success in the Light of Sirah

Prophet Muhammad: Allah’s Mercy to the Worlds and Favor to the Faithful
Zakat, Tattoos, and Movies
Zakat and Ramadan Issues
Wudu, Shab-e-Barat and Observance of Ramadan
Sajdah, Meaning of Makruh, Women and Jannah
Culture in Islam
Prenuptial Agreements, Non-practicing Parents, Zakat
Facial Plastic Surgery, Bell, Feet Covering, Fasting
Terrorism: A Crime against Allah and Humanity
Partition for Women inside the Masjid
Distribution of Sadqah Money, Non-Muslims Relatives, Wudu
Martial Arts, Court Marriages, He for Allah
Issues and Questions
Are Marriages Made in Heaven? Nawafil Prayers
Number of Prophets, Qada Prayer, Women in Cemetery
How to Welcome the Month of Ramadan
Wudu, Salah, and Dawah
Preparing for Death, Marriage, Wearing T-Shirts in Masjid
Hands in Salat, Translation of Qur’an, and Student Loans
Areas of Cooperation between the Muslims in America and the Muslim World
Issues and Questions
Thanksgiving in Islam
The Natural and Man-made Disasters and Our Response: The Message of Eidul Fitr 1426
Importance of Islamic Environment
The Makkah Declaration of Muslim Heads of State
Disability Insurance, Madhahib and Migration
Husband and Wife Fighting, Hijra & Muharram
14 things to remember for Eid day
Engagement, Poetry, and Qada' Prayers
Women Imams, Circumcision, Non-Muslims in the Masjid
Islamic Worldview: An Invitation to Proper Thought and Action
New Year of Hijrah 1427: A Time of Reflection and Renewal
Freedom of Expression or Freedom to Abuse
Natural Disasters: Punishment or Test from Allah (SWT)?
Al-Istihza’bi al-Din: Mockery or Making Fun of Religion
Sad and Painful News from Iraq Relations between Sunnis and Shi‘is
Love of Prophet Muhammad – peace be upon him
Burial, Visiting Spouse's Relatives

The Last Sermon of the Prophet
Working for Peace in This World
True Wisdom: The Source of Abundant Fortune
Prophet ‘Isa (Jesus) –peace be upon him - and the Controversy around the Da Vinci Code
Truth, Honesty and Good Relations
Workers Justice in Islam
A Clash of Civilizations or A Civilization of Clashes?
Is there Fascism in Islam?

The Spiritual and Moral Health of the Heart
Respect of Nature and Natural Resources
From Ignorance to Enlightenment: The Achievement of Prophet Muhammad – Peace be upon him
Working Together: A Human Necessity and an Islamic Mandate
Ihsan: The Art of Living in Islam
Ethical Judgment in Islam
The Role of Masajid and Islamic Schools in Muslim Life
Pure Faith and Righteous Actions: Muslim Character
Building Alliances: Promoting Goodness in the World
Metamorphosis of a Culture: Being Muslim Americans
Salat: The Key to Good Life

The Makkah Appeal for Interfaith Dialogue
Bridging the Generation Gap
Avoid Corruption, Seek Mercy and Be Merciful
Concept of Human Dignity: Its Implications and Applications
Independence Day: A Day of Celebration and a Day of Responsibility
Dealing with the Financial Crisis
Marriage and Family Life in Islam
Some Comments on Proposition 8 and Domestic Violence

Participation in the Society and Voting for Muslims in America
Domestic Violence: A Crime and a Sin
The Ten Commandments: Allah’s Universal Message
Fatwa and Its Importance in Islam
Ummah: Characteristics of a Model Community
Brotherhood and Sisterhood in Islam
Faith and Morality: Two Interconnected Aspects of Islam
Welcoming the Month of Ramadan
The Pillars of Islam: The Shahadah and Its Affects
Dealing with Others: The Islamic Perspective

Prophet Muhammad: A Rahmah for the Worlds
Sources of Dynamism in Islam

Prophet Muhammad: A Rahmah for the Worlds
Prophet Muhammad: The Good News
Basic Commitments of Muslims
What It Means to Be a Muslim Today?

Basic Philosophy and Objectives of the Shari'ah


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 . All Rights Reserved.