By Syed Arif Hussaini

May 16 , 2008

‘The Culture of Tolerance’ - A Bold, Provocative and Discordant Book

“The Culture of Tolerance” is the title of a scholarly work of Syed Osman Sher whose letters and articles have appeared, from time to time, in Pakistan Link also. A civil servant who has held senior positions both in Pakistan and abroad, he migrated to Canada years back to spend his post-retirement years with his sons.    
His account of the entry into India of waves after waves of foreign invaders and immigrants and their interaction with the local populace and assimilation into the local cultural milieu is, more or less, in line with similar accounts of other historians. But, his interpretations of the facts of history, in regard to the two-nation theory, do not appear to be based on a pursuit of strict objectivity and an appreciation of the postulates leading up to the partition of the country.
They might also offer an affront to the susceptibilities of those nurtured solely on the concept the two-nation theory.  For, he contends that the two-nation theory was a myth generated and fostered by the British to facilitate and prolong their rule. The harmonious amalgam of Hindu and Muslim social and cultural practices had given rise to ‘a new Indian race’, he contends.
In his own words, ‘The fabric of society which was woven with diverse strands for one thousand years was torn into shreds during the British rule which created intolerance within its fold. It is a historical fact, he argues, that the imperial British have been very faithful to their old colonial policy of ‘divide and rule’ and then divide for ever.
 The Muslim rule in India, spanning over six centuries (1193-1857) is generally divided into two periods. The first (1193-1526) witnessed five successive Turko-Afghan dynasties. The second period of the Mughal Empire covered the period 1526-1857.
None of the Sultans or the Mughals interfered with the indigenous culture, traditions and faith. Many had Hindu mothers. Conversion to Islam was voluntary. The greatest impediment in the development of a composite culture during these centuries, accepts Sher, was the hold of the Brahman under the caste system.
Even a powerful monarch like Akbar could not succeed in effecting a synthesis of the two religions despite going to the extent of giving up his own faith in favor of a new creed, Deen-I-Ilahi,  which he thought should be acceptable to both communities. It was not. He died advocating a synthesis of the two creeds and cultures. Even his mausoleum adds a feature of Ellora caves of ancient India to its Turkish architecture.
The caste system based on discrimination by birth was so entrenched in the Hindu society that neither the Sultans nor the Mughal could make a dent into it. Nor, did they make a deliberate attempt at that. Being the rulers, the monarchs, their courtiers, aristocrats and even the common Muslim masses tolerated the pretensions of the Brahmans to superiority by birth.
In the caste hierarchy, the Muslims were placed in the bottom category of the untouchables.  Since they belonged to the ruling community, the higher caste Hindus did not treat them with the disrespect and disdain that was meted out to the untouchables of their own community. It was this intolerance built into the Hindu society by the caste system that led to virtual revolts against it in the form of Bhuddism, Jainism and Sikhism. These movements were eventually absorbed into the Hindu fold.  This faculty to absorb into the Hindu milieu alien beliefs created serious apprehension in the mind of the Muslim community.
The interaction between the two major Indian communities, claims Sher, was ‘so strong that sometimes they seemed to be merging with each other even in matters of religion. Both communities participated and mingled with each other in the cultural fairs and religious festivals like Dipavali, Holi, Ram Lila, Bansant, Eid, Muharram and Urs of Muslim saints…Today the Muslims of the subcontinent belong to various castes, higher or lower, by descent or by profession.’ 
Sher’s finding of a synthesis in values of the two communities is not shared by many other historians. For instance R.C. Majumdar, a well-respected Hindu historian, says, ‘Henceforth there were two communities in India, Hindus and Muslims, who formed two entirely separate entities, so far at least as religious and social ideas and political and civil rights were concerned.’  
Another historian of no less prominence, K.K. Aziz, found the movements of Kabir, Nanak, Tukaram, Chaitanya etc. for a harmonious intermix of the two communities and their beliefs, as ‘a subtle Hindu move to subvert Islam’. ‘Hinduism, far from compromising with Islam was actually manifesting its remarkable capacity for synthesis.’
Nirad Chaudhari, in his book of international fame “The Autobiography of An Unknown Indian” mentions the fact that orthodox Hindus would take a bath after the day’s business if it has brought them into contact with non-Hindus.
Dr. I.H. Qureshi, a world-known teacher of history, points out in one of his books that once a Hindu converted to Islam, he adopted a Muslim name, and ‘broke all conscious ties with the culture of the society to which he had belonged, and integrated himself into the Muslim community.’
As a humble student of history, I find it difficult to share the views of Sher that it was a satanic scheme of the British to divide the Indians. The communal conflict was their handiwork to prolong their rule over India.
The Hindu-Muslim antagonism was not merely religious or political, but was a clash of two separate civilizations. The incompatibility of the two people was certainly not the creation of the British.  The British did exploit this immense breach in Indian unity. They would have been more than human if they had not.  And, I am also convinced that the chief villain in the interaction of the two communities was the uncompromising adherence of the high caste Hindus to the caste System.
Mahatama Gandhi, a great social reformer, in his efforts to give dignity to the lowliest went to the extent of cleaning himself latrines. He called the shudras, the children of God. Yet he failed and was brutally murdered by an upper caste Hindu.
The treatment meted out to Pholan Devi by the high caste Hindus, her revenge and her murder, epitomize the deep-rooted bane of the system and its continuing evil effects.
With the spread of education particularly among women, and an expanding economy providing vast job opportunities, the grip of the system is loosening but slowly and imperceptibly.  Would it take another half a century to kick out completely the obnoxious system? Would the leaders on both sides of the border continue with the blame game ad nauseum?
The current fast pace of economic growth and the economy’s pressing demands for well-educated and talented youth – irrespective of their lineage and descent -  is causing the erosion of the caste restrictions and of elitism on both sides of the border, auguring well for the future of the people at large in the subcontinent. A culture of tolerance, as portrayed by Sher, is gradually replacing the aura of mutual suspicions. 
Meanwhile, let us not miss reading the thought-provoking book of Osman Sher. He may be reached at: Osman_Sher@yahoo.com
arifhussaini@hotmail.com

 

 

 

 

PREVIOUSLY

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification
March 23 - Memories & Nostalgia
Deeper Malaise of Pakistan Polity
BJP’s Debacle in the Battle for Ballots
Feudalism’s Aversion to Education
Forgetfulness -a Prank of Old Age or of Hyperfocus
The Taliban and Beyond
Meetings of World Economic Forum and Its Counterweight
BJP Fails Again to Frame Pakistan
Indo-Chinese Relations in Perspective
Taj Mahal and Indo-Pakistan Standoff
Grandma, Grandpa
'The Clash of Civilizations' : A Questionable Thesis
In the Gadgeteer's Dreamland
Emergence of MMA on Pak Political Landscape
Chechnya and Moscow's Hostage Crisis
Turkish Elections in Historical Perspective
Iraq's Oil Wealth
America: A Nation on Wheels
"Jinnah & Pakistan" - A Worthwhile Book
Afghanistan Merits More Attention

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

In Memory of Dr. Hamidullah

Tackling Murphy at the Airport

Musings of a Superannuated Man

US Economy: Will Bush's Plan Work

Tempo of Life in AmericaThe Genius behind the MouseThe Media Mogul Who Manipulated Men and EventsHearst and Disney: A Comparative StudyNothing but the TruthWar on Iraq Imminent and InevitableMahathir's Interesting ViewsPortents of a New World OrderMarch 23 - Memories & NostalgiaRachel Corrie & the Spotted OwlLost in CyberspaceThe American Nice GuyismConnecticut - A Nursery of MenOn a Visit to Canada after Half of CenturySome Legal Aspects of the Iraq WarBureaucratic AnticsRhode Island: An Oxymoron, a ParadoxThe Mystique of CaliforniaComic Operas in Islamabad & in TexasKhyber Knights: A Fascinating BookG-8 Summit Skirts Touchy IssuesIn Memory of a Versatile GeniusHillary Clinton's Cleverly Crafted BookChitranwala Katora and ChutkiyanThe Yak Shows : The Trash TalksThe Giants of Sequoia National ParkReflections on Pakistan's Independence DayAziz Kay 'Sifarati Maarkay And Mujtaba Kay 'Safarnamay'California's Political CircusLali Chaudhri's Provocative Short StoriesSeptember: A Witness to WarsAmerica in the Quagmire of IraqCollapse of Another WTO SummitA B C D: American-Born-Clear-Headed DesisThe Pangs of WaitingChechnya: A Ray of Hope for PeaceAmerican Job Exodus to ChinaIslamabad : Its Beauty & OdditiesWelcome Proposals to Break Indo-Pak LogjamBenazir's Case and the Corruption ScenarioPredicament of Pakistan's PolityWhen Memory Starts FalteringTerror in Turkey Unrelated to Nation's Cultural ConflictThe Siren Song of Sale and Savings Wrinkles in US-China RelationsWrinkles in US-China RelationsSaddam Crawls out of a Hole to IgnominySaddam Crawls out of a Hole to IgnominyWhen Memory Starts FalteringA Day in the Company of Mujtaba HussainHyderabad Presents a Panorama of Progress and ChangeConflict over New World Economic OrderPakistan's Nuclear ScandalUrdu in Hyderabad DeccanA Good Book on a Great ManGay Marriages in Vivacious San FranciscoThe Passion of the Christ - A Well-Sculpted but Fuss-Causing FilmA Treat of Mujtaba's Wit and HumorPredicament of Pakistan's PolityThe Murder of Sheikh Yassin: Israel's Hidden AgendaArmy Action in Pakistan's Tribal BeltWould the NSC Buttress or Besiege Democracy?Desire and the Culture of Instant GratificationSwiss Court and the Benazir-Zardari Plunder SagaPakistan and the International Economic ForumsWhy Do US Follies Keep Piling up in Iraq?The Tamasha at Lahore AirportIndian Elections and Subsequent DevelopmentsBush Flaunts His Faulty Policies on IraqPost Civil War America and Post-Independence PakistanBureaucratic AnticsTackling Murphy at the AirportAsma's Fascinating Book on IslamAPPNA Qissa - 25 Years of Activities of Pak-American DoctorsBureacratic AnticsNightmare in SudanIn Pursuit of TerroristsWhy Turkey's Entry into European Union Is Blocked?Forgetfulness - A Prank of Old Age or of HyperfocusKremlin's Inept Tackling of Chechen ExtremistsWho Should Get My Vote In November Election?Bush vs. Annan on Legal Status of Iraq WarRethinking the National Security of PakistanThe Brief Message

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification Is Iran the Next Target?

Dollar vs. Euro -A Question of Hegemony

Zardari’s Release Indicative of Reconciliation?The Siren Song of Sale and SavingsChristmastime – A Festive OccasionPak-China Ties Keep Growing FirmlyAmerican Shopping MallsTsunami - an Asian Disaster Dr. Cohen’s Thought-Provoking Work on PakistanAlice in the FreelandBalochistan: Crisis & Conflict Iran the Next Target, but The Common Man

Chechnya: Chaos to Continue in the CaucasusGlobal Warming and Emulators of the OstrichA Treat of Mujtaba’s Wit and Humor Reflections on the Idea of Pakistan‘Engaging India’ - A Valuable Book by Strobe Talbott
Memories & Nostalgia
American Nice GuyismBalochistan at the Verge of Revolutionary Changes?India as Seen by Early Muslim Chroniclers India, China Leading a Resurgent AsiaThe Pain at the Petrol Pump Mujtaba Husain - a Humorist Par Excellence Musings of a Superannuated Man in AmericaThe Pangs of WaitingChaos and Killings in Uzbekistan Prospects of the Pain at the Petrol Pump
French Voters Reject Proposed EU Constitution
Why Turkey’s Entry into European Union Is Being BlockedWhat Ails Thee, My Native Land?The Deeper Malaise of Pakistan’s PolityResistance to Change in the System Feudalism’s Aversion to EducationRhode Island: An Oxymoron, a ParadoxThe Spotted Owl Wins against Bush AdministrationSufi Sage of Philadelphia and His Devotee from TorontoTo Ease the Pain at the Petrol PumpPat Robertson - a Loose Canon?Monkey Menace in New DelhiSeptember - A Witness to WarsThe Trouble with Islam Today Two Revealing Books on AfghanistanTo Lighten the Tedium of Air Travel
Islamabad as I Remember It
China’s White Paper Upholds Its “Democratic Dictatorship”The Brief MessageHalloween: The Fun-Filled FantasyPractical Joking: The Sport of Creeps?Senate Rebuffs Bush on War in IraqBush’s Unproductive Visit to ChinaGlobal Warming or Terrorism: Which Is a Bigger Threat?A High Achiever Shows the WaySyriana - An Expose of Intrigues of Oil CompaniesHow Washington Sold Its Soul for Saudi CrudeAlice in the FreelandAmerican EnglishThe Battle of the BulgeLost in CyberspaceHamas Vote Victory Invites Wrath of the WestNo Relief in Sight from Pain at the Petrol PumpPolitics of the Cartoons’ ControversyFollies & Fantasies of the FreaksMujtaba’s New Book and Urdu Magazine ‘Al Aqreba’Bush’s South Asian VisitFeudalism’s Aversion to Education

Mergers and Cartels Produce Unprecedented Oil Profits?

V for Vendetta – A Controversial Political Thriller A Treat of Mujtaba’s Wit and Humor Media Buzz on Invasion of IranChina’s Charm OffensiveTo Pump or Not to Pump, That Is Not the QuestionUndocumented Immigrants, No Social PariahsBush’s Subtle Approach to Immigration Issue The Da Vinci Code – A Mega Money Minter Randolph Hearst: The Media Mogul Hearst and Disney: A Comparative Study Pakistan’s Political Scenario Portends Violence but No Basic ChangeChatty Columns of a Remarkable Young WomanMountbatten Messed up Partition of IndiaChechnya after Blast Kills Its Rebel LeaderBombay Blasts and Some Reflections on TerrorismA Good Addition to Urdu Literature Lieberman’s Defeat in Democratic Primary Asifa Nishat - a Deep Thinking Urdu PoetWar In Iraq: The Crucial Issue in Midterm ElectionsBalochistan: Shape of Things to Come Khalid Khaja - an Eminent Urdu Poet, Writer & SpeakerSeptember - a Witness to Wars Military Coup in Thailand Triggers ReminiscencesMusharraf Pulls No Punches in His MemoirHasan Chishti - a Man of Letters, a Purveyor of HappinessHalloween: The Fun-Filled Fantasy Practical Joking: The Sport of Creeps? To Lighten the Tedium of Air Travel Bajaur: Action against Religious Seminary Raises QuestionsRumsfeld’s Exit Marks the Beginning of Shift of Course in IraqBorat: A Comedy of Discomfort and of Even OutrageRuler Derby in PakistanNO God But GOD - A Rational Account of Islam & A Call For ReformationTo Ease the Pain at the Petrol Pump Christmastime - a Festive OccasionJimmy Carter Exposes Oppression & Apartheid by Israel

India & China Lead Resurgent AsiaProspects of Pain at the Petrol PumpA Highly Informative and Thought-Provoking BookSomalia: Ethiopia Rides the TigerPakistan: The Shifting Political ScenarioMujtaba Hussain - A Purveyor of HappinessSurge in Suicide Blasts in PakistanSpecter of War Haunting IranFrenzied Fanatic Fells Female MinisterMusharraf Overtly Pressured and Covertly Remonstrated Suspension of Pak Chief Justice Triggers ControversyMarch 23: Memories & NostalgiaThe Ruler Derby in PakistanProspects of the Pain at Petrol PumpAmerican Islam: An Investigative StudyTurmoil in the Tribal Belt of Pakistan?A Scholar’s Gripping Account of Hyderabadi DiasporaOn Being a Senior CitizenTurkey: In the Cleft of a Cultural ConflictLost in CyberspaceAkbar Ahmad’s Book on Current Challenges to Muslim SocietiesAsma’s Fascinating Book on IslamIrshad Manji Points out the Trouble with Islam Today A Scholar’s Plea for the Resumption of IjtehadThe Mystique of CaliforniaKnighthood for Salman RushdieUpheaval in Palestine: National Objective in Ruins“Jinnah & Pakistan” – A Worthwhile BookLal Masjid and Beyond

Musings of a Superannuated Man
Significance of General Elections in Turkey Musharraf-Benazir Tango to the Tune Called by the USReflections on Independence DayNostalgia for the HomelandPakistan: The Corruption Scenario Changing Political Dynamic in PakistanPakistan: Current Political Crisis and the Common ManThe Battle of the BulgeOn Being a Senior CitizenWhen Memory Starts Faltering (1)The Musharraf-Benazir Deal: Its Nature & FutureHalloween: A Fun-Filled Fantasy Is Pakistan the Most Dangerous Nation?Lost in CyberspaceSurge of Violence in PakistanWhat Ails Thee, My Native Land?

Washington’s Fear Mongers Focus on Pakistan’s Nukes

Akbar Ahmad’s Book on Current Challenges to Muslim Societies
The Startling US Intelligence Report on Iran’s Nuclear Plan
Christmastime: A Festive Occasion
Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification
Bhutto’s Murder Plunges Pakistan Deep into Turmoil
Would Musharraf Be Able to Weather the Storm?
Feudalism’s Aversion to Education
‘Charlie Wilson’s War’ – A Film Based on a Best-Seller Book
The Kite Runner: An Absorbing Book, a Wonderful Film
Hillary Clinton - First Woman to Bid for the White House
Whither Pakistan?
Who Should Get My Vote?
Pakistan: The Emerging Political Scenario
More Pain at the Petrol Pump
On Being a Senior Citizen
Sufi Sage of Philadelphia and His Devotee from Toronto
‘The Pakistani Bride’ – A Gripping Novel by Bapsi Sidhwa
New Pak Premier Faces Daunting Tasks
The Mystique of California
Mark Twain: America’s Greatest Humorist
Jimmy Carter Exposes Oppression & Apartheid
‘The Trial of Dara Shikoh’ - A Thought-Provoking Play
No Reprieve from the Pain at the Gas Station


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 pakistanlink.com . All Rights Reserved.