By Syed Arif Hussaini


The Deeper Malaise of Pakistan’s Polity

July 01, 2005


The crux of the problem of Pakistani polity lies in the dichotomy between the rulers and the ruled. While the gap has kept narrowing in both India and Bangladesh, it has been widening and solidifying in Pakistan. The governments of the neighboring countries have been responsive to the aspirations of the people, who in their turn have reposed trust in governments elected by them. Both societies have been marching forward at a fast clip over the past decade or two.
In the first three decades after independence, Pakistan too had registered a laudable economic growth rate, perhaps the highest in South Asia. Its progress in the social sector was also quite impressive. What went wrong, then? One has to look into the historical factors.
The British left behind in the subcontinent a tradition of dual forms of governance – the authoritarian (Vice-regal) and the parliamentary.
The areas that constitute Pakistan now came under the British Raj a century or so after the annexation of eastern, southern and north central areas of India. While the liberal values of British education and rule were taking roots in UP, Bengal, Bombay, CP and Madras etc. and the people were getting accustomed to the rule of law, justice and the tolerance of dissent, bulk of North-Western India continued to be under the authoritarian rule of Raja Ranjeet Singh – Sikha Shahi - till its annexation by the East India Company in 1849 – over ninety years after the fall of Bengal to the British in the Battle of Plassey (1757).
The British found in the Northwest a strong tradition of rule by dictat and command, and therefore an incredible respect for authority. The Vice regal system of rule was thus found suitable for the area. The process of decision-making followed in this area was largely in the descending order, while in the other areas it was in the ascending order.
Debate and discussion of an issue was allowed in the ascending process to commence at the desk of a subordinate official and to continue upwards even to the level of the Viceroy. The decision thus taken reflected the cumulative intellect of all the concerned functionaries –elected or part of the bureaucratic structure.
The officers and staff who had opted to serve in Pakistan brought this system of decision-making to Karachi from New Delhi. It remained in operation till the entire process was subjected to the authoritarian system by the Martial Law regime of Ayub Khan.
“Democracy does not suit the genius of the people”, he proclaimed. But being a moderate person and a product of the British system, he reverted within four years to a Constitutional government, normal operation of the rule of law and the process of debate and discussion. His effective advisers were outstanding civil servants nurtured on the ascending order of decision-making. His ten-year rule therefore witnessed laudable progress in all socio-economic sectors.
The first major jolt to the system, particularly to the economy, was given by Z. A. Bhutto, who had emerged as a populist leader but on the assumption of power elected to don the mantel of a Martial Law Administrator. Under the protective shield of Martial Law, he nationalized all major industries in the name of social justice, blunting their competitive edge on the world market. More importantly, he destroyed by this measure the political clout of the growing urban-based industrialists.
The ensuing vacuum served as a political windfall to the rural aristocracy, the feudal lords, Bhutto’s own caste.
A narcissistic feudal lord and a dyed-in-the wool autocrat, he exploited the pent-up emotions of the downtrodden people calling them “the fountainhead of all power”. He rode to power on this very slogan. The credulous people believed him. Despite this hypocrisy, history would not fail to credit him with causing an awakening among the masses. And, the people reciprocated by electing twice his corrupt and incompetent daughter to power.
Had he practiced what he preached, Pakistan would not be in the sorry state that it is now.
He had the best opportunity after the fall of Dacca to cut the warrior caste to its proper size. It was ready to accept the surgery to make up for the disgraceful surrender. Instead of cutting it down by at least half, as the defense of the Eastern wing was no longer the responsibility of the rump state, he fired a few "fat and flabby" generals but more than doubled the defense spending! He selected a junior, meek and ostensibly submissive general - Ziaul Haq - as his army chief and thought that he had thereby strengthened his control over the army.
This was the greatest folly of Bhutto. Instead of strengthening the civil polity, he opened the official largesse to the warrior caste and enlarged it beyond the possibility of control by civilian authority. He had to pay with his life for this aberration from his populist posture. His feudal and autocratic proclivity overrode his commitment to the common people. The ray of dignity and respect in the life of the common man had disappeared!!
The nation was thrown back to the autocratic Sikha Shahi period. A nominated Majlis-i-Shura or a parliament drawn through non-party elections was Zia’s facade for his military dictatorship.
He served as the American surrogate in the Afghan war that ensured his continuance in the seat of power for 12 long years. Economy, education and other national issues of real significance were put on the back burners. The fallout of the war in the form of Klashnikov culture, smuggling, heroin abuse and the onslaught of 3.5 million Afghan refugees was brushed under the carpet. These became big headaches for all subsequent governments.
The US ensured that Zia’s attention was not diverted from the Afghan arena. IMF, World Bank and the Paris Club were made to dole out on occasions more loans than what Zia’s minions requested. No wonder external debt shot up during his period from $5 billion to $18 billion.
Unfortunately, he was too self-serving, too obsequious, to even mention to his masters to write off the debt for the sacrifices of his nation. Egypt got this done at the time of the Camp David Accord.
When Zia left, the economy had already entered the debt trap. From then onwards efforts concentrated on borrowing more and more to pay the due installments and the interest on earlier debts, fund the ever increasing demands of armed forces, and cover the gap even in the revenue budget.
Puny civilian leaders – Junejo, Benazir and Nawaz Sharif - had neither the vision nor the courage to take unpleasant decisions to rectify the situation. Instead of going to the people to inspire them for the needed sacrifices, they turned for support to the feudal elite. The country came to be dominated by the feudal spirit: arrogance, self-aggrandizement, and finding a way out of any problem through harassment or by lining the pockets of concerned high officials.
Nawaz Sharif’s release from jail and exile in Saudi Arabia provide convincing evidence of his family’s expertise in using money to achieve their objectives.
Born and raised in the feudal environment, Benazir is unwilling to return to the nation her ill-gotten wealth or defend her innocence in a court of law. The miasma of her and her husband’s corruption still permeates the society. During her two stints, she did throw some crumbs to the minions of the PPP but did little for the common weal.
From all indications, the military domination is likely to stay in the country far beyond the time given to it by the Supreme Court. The military leader, Gen. Musharraf, has taken since 9/11 decisions that have been lauded by all sectors of the society. He has tried to establish a rapport with the people at all levels, and has taken them into confidence on major decisions affecting their future. He has, however, been taciturn on the evil spirit of feudalism that haunts the society. There is no feudalism in either India or in Bangladesh; both have multi-layered elected institutions and strong bureaucracies.
Gen. Musharraf views the system of local governments introduced by him as the panacea for the ill effects of the hiatus between the rulers and the ruled. The administrative and financial powers granted to these basic institutions are expected to unleash the creative energies of the common people. If these institutions slip once more into the hands of feudal oligarchies, the frustration building up within the national pressure cooker would reach sooner than later the point of implosion.
- arifhussaini@hotmail.com

 



PREVIOUSLY

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification
March 23 - Memories & Nostalgia
Deeper Malaise of Pakistan Polity
BJP’s Debacle in the Battle for Ballots
Feudalism’s Aversion to Education
Forgetfulness -a Prank of Old Age or of Hyperfocus
The Taliban and Beyond
Meetings of World Economic Forum and Its Counterweight
BJP Fails Again to Frame Pakistan
Indo-Chinese Relations in Perspective
Taj Mahal and Indo-Pakistan Standoff
Grandma, Grandpa
'The Clash of Civilizations' : A Questionable Thesis
In the Gadgeteer's Dreamland
Emergence of MMA on Pak Political Landscape
Chechnya and Moscow's Hostage Crisis
Turkish Elections in Historical Perspective
Iraq's Oil Wealth
America: A Nation on Wheels
"Jinnah & Pakistan" - A Worthwhile Book
Afghanistan Merits More Attention

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

In Memory of Dr. Hamidullah

Tackling Murphy at the Airport

Musings of a Superannuated Man

US Economy: Will Bush's Plan Work

Tempo of Life in America

The Genius behind the Mouse

The Media Mogul Who Manipulated Men and Events

Hearst and Disney: A Comparative Study

Nothing but the Truth

War on Iraq Imminent and Inevitable

Mahathir's Interesting Views

Portents of a New World Order

March 23 - Memories & Nostalgia

Rachel Corrie & the Spotted Owl

Lost in Cyberspace

The American Nice Guyism

Connecticut - A Nursery of Men

On a Visit to Canada after Half of Century

Some Legal Aspects of the Iraq War

Bureaucratic Antics

Rhode Island: An Oxymoron, a Paradox

The Mystique of California

Comic Operas in Islamabad & in Texas

Khyber Knights: A Fascinating Book

G-8 Summit Skirts Touchy Issues

In Memory of a Versatile Genius

Hillary Clinton's Cleverly Crafted Book

Chitranwala Katora and Chutkiyan

The Yak Shows : The Trash Talks

The Giants of Sequoia National Park

Reflections on Pakistan's Independence Day

Aziz Kay 'Sifarati Maarkay And Mujtaba Kay 'Safarnamay'

California's Political Circus

Lali Chaudhri's Provocative Short Stories

September: A Witness to Wars

America in the Quagmire of Iraq

Collapse of Another WTO Summit

A B C D: American-Born-Clear-Headed Desis

The Pangs of Waiting

Chechnya: A Ray of Hope for Peace

American Job Exodus to China

Islamabad : Its Beauty & Oddities

Welcome Proposals to Break Indo-Pak Logjam

Benazir's Case and the Corruption Scenario

Predicament of Pakistan's Polity

When Memory Starts Faltering

Terror in Turkey Unrelated to Nation's Cultural Conflict

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

Wrinkles in US-China Relations

Wrinkles in US-China Relations

Saddam Crawls out of a Hole to Ignominy

Saddam Crawls out of a Hole to Ignominy

When Memory Starts Faltering

A Day in the Company of Mujtaba Hussain

Hyderabad Presents a Panorama of Progress and Change

Conflict over New World Economic Order

Pakistan's Nuclear Scandal

Urdu in Hyderabad Deccan

A Good Book on a Great Man

Gay Marriages in Vivacious San Francisco

The Passion of the Christ - A Well-Sculpted but Fuss-Causing Film

A Treat of Mujtaba's Wit and Humor

Predicament of Pakistan's Polity

The Murder of Sheikh Yassin: Israel's Hidden Agenda

Army Action in Pakistan's Tribal Belt

Would the NSC Buttress or Besiege Democracy?

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification

Swiss Court and the Benazir-Zardari Plunder Saga

Pakistan and the International Economic Forums

Why Do US Follies Keep Piling up in Iraq?

The Tamasha at Lahore Airport

Indian Elections and Subsequent Developments

Bush Flaunts His Faulty Policies on Iraq

Post Civil War America and Post-Independence Pakistan

Bureaucratic Antics

Tackling Murphy at the Airport

Asma's Fascinating Book on Islam

APPNA Qissa - 25 Years of Activities of Pak-American Doctors

Bureacratic Antics

Nightmare in Sudan

In Pursuit of Terrorists

Why Turkey's Entry into European Union Is Blocked?

Forgetfulness - A Prank of Old Age or of Hyperfocus

Kremlin's Inept Tackling of Chechen Extremists

Who Should Get My Vote In November Election?

Bush vs. Annan on Legal Status of Iraq War

Rethinking the National Security of Pakistan

The Brief Message

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification

Is Iran the Next Target?

Dollar vs. Euro -A Question of Hegemony

Zardari’s Release Indicative of Reconciliation?

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

Christmastime – A Festive Occasion

Pak-China Ties Keep Growing Firmly

American Shopping Malls

Tsunami - an Asian Disaster

Dr. Cohen’s Thought-Provoking Work on Pakistan

Alice in the Freeland

Balochistan: Crisis & Conflict

Iran the Next Target, but

The Common Man

Chechnya: Chaos to Continue in the Caucasus

Global Warming and Emulators of the OstrichA

Treat of Mujtaba’s Wit and Humor

Reflections on the Idea of Pakistan

‘Engaging India’ - A Valuable Book by Strobe Talbott
Memories & Nostalgia

American Nice Guyism

Balochistan at the Verge of Revolutionary Changes?

India as Seen by Early Muslim Chroniclers

India, China Leading a Resurgent Asia

The Pain at the Petrol Pump

Mujtaba Husain - a Humorist Par Excellence

Musings of a Superannuated Man in America

The Pangs of Waiting

Chaos and Killings in Uzbekistan

Prospects of the Pain at the Petrol Pump
French Voters Reject Proposed EU Constitution

Why Turkey’s Entry into European Union Is Being Blocked

What Ails Thee, My Native Land?


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 pakistanlink.com . All Rights Reserved.