By Syed Arif Hussaini

September 30, 2005

The Trouble with Islam Today

Irshad Manji, author of the book under the above title, has been called a heretic, a self-despising person, an Islamophobic out to wage a vendetta on the faith she was born into. Yet, the 216-page book is compelling, riveting and thought provoking, despite being no highbrow work of history or scholarship.
It is as intriguing as the author herself. Take her very name, Irshad, for instance. This is the first time to my knowledge at least that a Muslim girl has been given the name of a boy. She calls it a ‘unisex’ name - she ought to know, it is her name. Then, she is a Lesbian and makes no bones about it. “God has made me and only God can unravel me”, she contends.
Manji, 37, has earned repute as an experienced journalist, a lecturer much in demand and a devout human rights fighter. She is the winner of numerous awards including Opra Winfrey’s Chutzpah Award for courage, verve and conviction, and Simon Wiesenthal Award for valor. She has been hosting a TV program dealing with the issues of Gays and Lesbians titled Queer TV as well as the program Big Ideas.
Born in Uganda to a martinet Indian father and a soft and considerate Egyptian mother, both Muslims, Irshad arrived in Richmond, B.C., Canada in 1972 along with her parents who were expelled from Uganda by Idi Amin. She was just four years of age. She was a student leader at school and in college. And, her parents sent her to a Muslim madarsa attached to a mosque for several years to enable her to be educated in the religion of her family.
That is where her confusion and conflict began. Her teacher, evidently an honorary worker not well versed in religion, was unable to satisfy her questioning mind. Following the ‘my way or the highway’ dogma, he made her quit the class. But she continued to study Islam on her own, by borrowing books from a library, for some 20 years. Naturally, she had no opportunity to learn Arabic and she had to depend on the works of orientalists; a list of the books is given on her website (WWW.Muslim-Refusenik.com) and at the end of her book.
In a way it is advantageous that her thoughts did not get steeped into the plethora of literature on Islam produced during the period 750-1492, the golden period of Islam’s intellectual, material and scientific attainments. She has computed this period to be 500 years, from750 to 1250, but I think the momentum continued, though it was tapering off till the fall of Spain in 1492 that also marks the discovery of America.
She attributes most of the troubles of the Muslim world to the drying up of the spirit of enquiry, Ijtehad, by Muslim religious leaders in the 12th century and those who have followed in their footsteps. The door of Ijtehad was shut to do away with the hundreds of different schools of thought that had cropped up creating a cacophony of dissident voices. Then, the mystics and Sufis established their own cadres adhering to mysterious rituals. Yet, as Manji has pointed out, the end of Ijtehad marked the end of the dialectics of debates, discussions, syntheses and consensus. Islam went into a hermitage.
The spirit of enquiry, the distinctive feature of the Muslim intellectual life was picked up by Christian reformers, Martin Luther, Calvin and others. Renaissance and the Industrial Revolution, growth of pure and applied sciences generated fast forward march of Europe. Muslim empires of Turkey, Iran and India commenced their slide down till their territories and resources were taken over by Western colonialism and enterprise.
The muzzle over innovation imposed by the mullahs, the clergy, was so severe that an observatory set up in Istanbul in 1579 was demolished a year later. The great Ottoman Empire continued in intellectual darkness for two more centuries when a printing press in Istanbul was closed in 1745! Printing press was an innovation, hence unacceptable to the clergy. What a plunge from a few centuries before, points out the author, when Islam led the world in astronomy, math, medicine, and more.
Manji attribute many of the faults of Muslim communities in various parts of the world to the emergence of Wahabism in mid 18th century in collaboration with the house of Saud. She calls it Fundamentalism and Desert Islam. She does not mention the positive attainments of Wahabism – a puritan form of religion free of ancestor and grave worship and Sufi practices and sects. The concept that the 32-year period of the four Caliphs who followed the prophet, marked the golden era of Islam, is open to question. Three of the four Caliphs were assassinated and by Muslims, and the entire period is too short to serve as the role model for generations to follow. But that kept the focus of the worldwide Muslim community on practices followed by Saudi Arabia. “When people are indoctrinated to believe that any aspect of the founding moment is sacred”, argues Manji, “then the faith is destined to become static, brittle, inhumane”. Arab culture needs to be separated from Islam as a faith, she maintains.
Manji is right in her argument that the Muslims have to throw open the door of Ijtehad, instead of remaining confined to their own cocoons of tribal practices, superstitions and unquestioning following of rituals. A radical reformer, she questions refreshingly the prevalent concepts, provoking thought and exercising logic. She eggs on Muslims to do a lot of introspection. Her tone is urgent, insistent and unmodulated to the point of being tedious at times. She is unhappy over the erosion of intellectual curiosity among Muslims for so many centuries.
She has launched a project for introducing Ijtehad into the body politics of Muslim societies. A Foundation has been set up to enable Muslim youth to get together and exchange views – a cross fertilization of concepts.
She is also working on measures to empower rural women through micro loans. This too appears to be making headway. In Muslim countries a good number of women are in the field now for securing the rights of women and fighting against tribal and other traditions suppressing women.
The devaluation of women is not peculiar to Muslim societies only. Matter of fact, Islam liberated women of Arabia. Chinese used to for centuries tie the feet of young girls in wooden shoes so that they grew up as physically handicapped women to remain dependent on their husbands and other men of the family for the rest of their lives. I have a vivid recollection of such Chinese ladies whom I used to see as a young boy in mid 1930s.
In Hindu society, the custom of Satti obligated the widow to burn alive on the funeral pyre of her dead husband. That means the wife had no identity separate from that of her husband. In Arabia female babies were buried alive till Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) banned the custom. And, in Europe, women were burnt alive on suspicion of being witches. In Roman Empire a woman, like a slave, was treated like property.
Enlightenment and progress have gradually eliminated all these customs. Change for the better can be witnessed now everywhere. In some Muslim societies, however, there is still the tradition of honor killings, bias against homosexuals, defining rape victims as adulteresses, and punishing adulteresses by stoning. But there is a strong aversion building up towards these. And, laws are being framed to eliminate such malpractices. Irshad Manji need not be over-aggressive about these, as these practices too would follow Satti and foot-tying practices. One may disagree with the author on certain points, but it is a book worth reading and mulling over.
- arifhussaini@hotmail.com

 

PREVIOUSLY

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification
March 23 - Memories & Nostalgia
Deeper Malaise of Pakistan Polity
BJP’s Debacle in the Battle for Ballots
Feudalism’s Aversion to Education
Forgetfulness -a Prank of Old Age or of Hyperfocus
The Taliban and Beyond
Meetings of World Economic Forum and Its Counterweight
BJP Fails Again to Frame Pakistan
Indo-Chinese Relations in Perspective
Taj Mahal and Indo-Pakistan Standoff
Grandma, Grandpa
'The Clash of Civilizations' : A Questionable Thesis
In the Gadgeteer's Dreamland
Emergence of MMA on Pak Political Landscape
Chechnya and Moscow's Hostage Crisis
Turkish Elections in Historical Perspective
Iraq's Oil Wealth
America: A Nation on Wheels
"Jinnah & Pakistan" - A Worthwhile Book
Afghanistan Merits More Attention

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

In Memory of Dr. Hamidullah

Tackling Murphy at the Airport

Musings of a Superannuated Man

US Economy: Will Bush's Plan Work

Tempo of Life in America

The Genius behind the Mouse

The Media Mogul Who Manipulated Men and Events

Hearst and Disney: A Comparative Study

Nothing but the Truth

War on Iraq Imminent and Inevitable

Mahathir's Interesting Views

Portents of a New World Order

March 23 - Memories & Nostalgia

Rachel Corrie & the Spotted Owl

Lost in Cyberspace

The American Nice Guyism

Connecticut - A Nursery of Men

On a Visit to Canada after Half of Century

Some Legal Aspects of the Iraq War

Bureaucratic Antics

Rhode Island: An Oxymoron, a Paradox

The Mystique of California

Comic Operas in Islamabad & in Texas

Khyber Knights: A Fascinating Book

G-8 Summit Skirts Touchy Issues

In Memory of a Versatile Genius

Hillary Clinton's Cleverly Crafted Book

Chitranwala Katora and Chutkiyan

The Yak Shows : The Trash Talks

The Giants of Sequoia National Park

Reflections on Pakistan's Independence Day

Aziz Kay 'Sifarati Maarkay And Mujtaba Kay 'Safarnamay'

California's Political Circus

Lali Chaudhri's Provocative Short Stories

September: A Witness to Wars

America in the Quagmire of Iraq

Collapse of Another WTO Summit

A B C D: American-Born-Clear-Headed Desis

The Pangs of Waiting

Chechnya: A Ray of Hope for Peace

American Job Exodus to China

Islamabad : Its Beauty & Oddities

Welcome Proposals to Break Indo-Pak Logjam

Benazir's Case and the Corruption Scenario

Predicament of Pakistan's Polity

When Memory Starts Faltering

Terror in Turkey Unrelated to Nation's Cultural Conflict

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

Wrinkles in US-China Relations

Wrinkles in US-China Relations

Saddam Crawls out of a Hole to Ignominy

Saddam Crawls out of a Hole to Ignominy

When Memory Starts Faltering

A Day in the Company of Mujtaba Hussain

Hyderabad Presents a Panorama of Progress and Change

Conflict over New World Economic Order

Pakistan's Nuclear Scandal

Urdu in Hyderabad Deccan

A Good Book on a Great Man

Gay Marriages in Vivacious San Francisco

The Passion of the Christ - A Well-Sculpted but Fuss-Causing Film

A Treat of Mujtaba's Wit and Humor

Predicament of Pakistan's Polity

The Murder of Sheikh Yassin: Israel's Hidden Agenda

Army Action in Pakistan's Tribal Belt

Would the NSC Buttress or Besiege Democracy?

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification

Swiss Court and the Benazir-Zardari Plunder Saga

Pakistan and the International Economic Forums

Why Do US Follies Keep Piling up in Iraq?

The Tamasha at Lahore Airport

Indian Elections and Subsequent Developments

Bush Flaunts His Faulty Policies on Iraq

Post Civil War America and Post-Independence Pakistan

Bureaucratic Antics

Tackling Murphy at the Airport

Asma's Fascinating Book on Islam

APPNA Qissa - 25 Years of Activities of Pak-American Doctors

Bureacratic Antics

Nightmare in Sudan

In Pursuit of Terrorists

Why Turkey's Entry into European Union Is Blocked?

Forgetfulness - A Prank of Old Age or of Hyperfocus

Kremlin's Inept Tackling of Chechen Extremists

Who Should Get My Vote In November Election?

Bush vs. Annan on Legal Status of Iraq War

Rethinking the National Security of Pakistan

The Brief Message

Desire and the Culture of Instant Gratification

Is Iran the Next Target?

Dollar vs. Euro -A Question of Hegemony

Zardari’s Release Indicative of Reconciliation?

The Siren Song of Sale and Savings

Christmastime – A Festive Occasion

Pak-China Ties Keep Growing Firmly

American Shopping Malls

Tsunami - an Asian Disaster

Dr. Cohen’s Thought-Provoking Work on Pakistan

Alice in the Freeland

Balochistan: Crisis & Conflict

Iran the Next Target, but

The Common Man

Chechnya: Chaos to Continue in the Caucasus

Global Warming and Emulators of the OstrichA

Treat of Mujtaba’s Wit and Humor

Reflections on the Idea of Pakistan

‘Engaging India’ - A Valuable Book by Strobe Talbott
Memories & Nostalgia

American Nice Guyism

Balochistan at the Verge of Revolutionary Changes?

India as Seen by Early Muslim Chroniclers

India, China Leading a Resurgent Asia

The Pain at the Petrol Pump

Mujtaba Husain - a Humorist Par Excellence

Musings of a Superannuated Man in America

The Pangs of Waiting

Chaos and Killings in Uzbekistan

Prospects of the Pain at the Petrol Pump
French Voters Reject Proposed EU Constitution

Why Turkey’s Entry into European Union Is Being Blocked

What Ails Thee, My Native Land?

The Deeper Malaise of Pakistan’s Polity

Resistance to Change in the System

Feudalism’s Aversion to Education

Rhode Island: An Oxymoron, a Paradox

The Spotted Owl Wins against Bush Administration

Sufi Sage of Philadelphia and His Devotee from Toronto

To Ease the Pain at the Petrol Pump

Pat Robertson - a Loose Canon?

Monkey Menace in New Delhi

September - A Witness to Wars


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 pakistanlink.com . All Rights Reserved.