Modi’s Operandi: American Business & Genocide Linked Again?
By Moorthy Muthuswamy, PhD
New York

I would like to give a Hindu view on Narendra Modi’s visa revoke and related issues to the one given by a Muslim from India, Dr. Muqtedar Khan (Modi’s Operandi: American Business and Genocide Linked Again? March 26).
First of all, Dr. Khan has portrayed a one-sided view and without context. The riots occurred under Mr. Modi’s watch in the aftermath of gruesome burning of a training coach full of Hindu children, women and men pilgrims by a Muslim mob in Godhra, Gujarat. Even in the riots at least 20% of those killed were Hindus -- in the police firing conducted to quell the rioters.
From Muslim majority Indian Kashmir valley over 300,000 Hindus have been displaced and scores killed. A study conducted in 1970s showed that more than 95% of riots in India were started after Friday prayers by Muslims. Hence, the Godhra burning and the pattern of acts of violent acts by fundamentalists have built up great deal of anger and resentment in the minds of Hindu majority. All of the above had created a perception among Hindus that the governments will not be able to protect them and that they must act. The bottom line is communities should defend themselves from attack -- be it Muslims or non-Muslims.
Dr. Khan has failed to address the root cause - which is, how to help Muslim communities in South Asia avoid a confrontational path and work with other communities for mutual progress. But continuing to vilify Hindu community leaders and to apologize or ignore Muslim violence is not helpful.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 pakistanlink.com . All Rights Reserved.