By By Salma Malik

July 08,2011


“Carrying Forward the Engagement” Is Not Enough


GA_googleFillSlot("Dawn_ROS_Banner"); The India–Pakistan foreign secretary level meeting concluded on a happy and congenial note. Once again many promises were made, new directions chartered and pledges to make the process conclusive and positive have been reaffirmed. However, given the past record, it leaves the interested Indian-Pakistani audience with a mix message.

There have been many incidents in the past where the people have brought out their proverbial pompoms prematurely and played the cheerleaders, with little to celebrate in the end. Meetings which were initiated at a high note, only to turn sour, such as the Agra Summit or Krishna-Qureshi Meeting last year.

The statement followed by a press brief as such did not draw any conclusive lines, though an air of congeniality and cooperation was very much evident. One reason could be Nirupama Rao’s appointment as the next Indian envoy to the US, and hence a desire to leave a positive imprint on the process. But let’s not trivialize the process by bringing in personal stakes, as the last thing the process as fragile as ours can afford is an actor and not factor based input.

If we go by the body language of the two interlocutors, then it was a very relaxed, stress free and a happy one. Interestingly, the media spotlight was not so fully focused on the two perhaps deliberately, perhaps for the reason that there were hosts of other breaking news to make and break, such as the return of the stranded and captured merchant ship’s crew, forthcoming elections in AJK, discovery of a bomb outside a Shia mosque in Karachi etc. or at worst, it was an indifference towards the talks.

The talks concluded over the commitment to continue with the engagement, as put forth by Secretary Salman Bashir, plus there was empathy towards each others’ positions, especially over the sensitivity surrounding the Mumbai incident. On the other side, a muffled but clear hint towards conditionality with regards to the sustainability of the process was visible.

The talks laid out a framework for the resumption of talks beginning next month, plus acknowledgment of the need to settle Kashmir for the larger good of the affected population. However, a sobering reality check is that verdict is already out on the Siachen dispute – and that is a clear and solid no from the Indian military establishment, regarding a withdrawal. According to a WikiLeaks cable from 2006, “strategic advantage over China, internal army corruption, distrust of Pakistan and a desire to keep hold of advantageous territory that thousands of Indian soldiers have died protecting.”

The need to resolve the Siachen glacier issue is even supported strongly within the Indian intelligentsia circles, who acknowledge the futility of continuation of this engagement, which ends up claiming more lives not through enemy gunfire on both sides, as much as owing to the harsh and inhospitable weather. Besides, it also provides both sides with an excellent confidence building and diplomatic marksmanship opportunity both for domestic and external audience.

Alongside the modest advancement made on nuclear CBMs and risk reduction measures, since the initiation of the process, Siachen and Sir Creek issues have been considered to be minor irritants for which the routine statements issued are those of substantial progress being made, in order to placate the interested audiences. However, in reality, it is the distrust of not only the adversary, but internal actors, the fear of losing the heavily guarded and maintained clout of interest groups across the board and the reinforcement of a warped Meta narrative which is extremely important to run this conflict industry. The creators of this Meta narrative have successfully manipulated and tamed media to a larger extent to be the instruments of war mongering, given the amount of monetary investment done by some, however they err in underestimating the outreach and outgrowth of media. When Pakistan made the Kargil blunder, it learnt this lesson very well, from the neighboring channels the mantra of hyper nationalism at times adds to the prevailing suffocation.

However, if both sides honestly aim to not merely engage but enter a happy wedlock for the growth, progress and prosperity of their people, going by the rhetoric of the foreign secretaries, then the first step is to be honest to one’s own self and the need to re-visit history. Luckily for us, our history books only need to retrace sixty four years. We need to re-examine, what exactly is the Kashmir problem, who occupied Siachen first, and what have been the real cost of this occupation for each side, what were the rationale and outcomes of the various wars fought and where did the mapping over the Sir Creek go awry.

If we are successful in this introspection, the next step is to build mutual and internal trust, confidence and a strong peace constituency; the rest will fall in place. Till the mid 1990s, India and Pakistan chartered the same directional paths, however there has been a gradual to abrupt de-hyphenation as brought forth by the US, which has put them on totally different trajectories. The question is not about de-hyphenation alone, the issue is that we are conjoined twins, attempting to move in different directions, but remain bound to each other through our shared unsettled history. - Courtesy Dawn

( The writer is faculty member at the Defense & Strategic Studies Dept. at Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad)


An American Adventurer in Pakistan

Time to Break New Ground in Religious Thinking

Is There a Life After Kashmir?

Some Recollections on Year 2001

Celebrating Holidays Across Religious Divides

What Middle East Needs is a Miracle

A New Beginning for Afghanistan?

Kashmir & the War on Terrorism

At the Core of Pakista’s Woes

Our Insensitive Imams

The Core Issue

In the Aftermath of the Terrorist Attack

Time for Taleban to Roll up the Welcome Mat

The Later Day Trojan Horses

Some Thoughts on the Execution of Timothy McVeigh

Ancient Languages Wither Without a Sound

The Hallowed Ground Called the West End London, England

The Frontier Post- A Eulogy

The Emperor’s New Clothes

The Flowering of the Deobandi Movement

Of Mice and Human Brain Cells

Of Mice and Human Brain Cells

The Irrepressible English and Their Language

Costa Rica, An Unusual Country in Central America

Off the Depleted Uranium, Blown-out Tires and Heart Devices

Crossing the Rubicon in Toledo, Ohio

Taliban: Saviors of Afghanistan or Ignorant Zealots?

The Irrepressible English and their Language

Reality of Daily Life Meshes Old and New

An Arrogant Act Burns the Bridges to Peace

Time to Lift Iraqi Sanctions

The 'Doctor' Dispenses Self-Righteous Advis

Jihad University is Just Down the Road from the CIA

There Is Really no Free Lunch

Afrasiab Khattak: An Unlikely Crusader

The Lure of Love Bug

Medical Education and Medical Practice in Pakistan: Time to Sort Out the Mess

Peshawar: The city of contrasts

"You have been to Peshawar, I Perceive."

Effects of Random Violence Outlast Sympathy

A Cause Celebre for American Politicians

Celestial High-Handedness

Bike Trail Delights the Eye and Immigration

Can Mullah"s be Trusted to Run a Country?

Prophet Muhammad's Life and Deeds Still Resonate after 1400 Years

Of the Cantonments and British Sahibs

Turkey's 'Islamic Revolution'

Farewell to a Man of Passion and Grace

Attacks on Christians

The Forced Return of the Huddled Masses

Back to Likud Picks UP

Crossing the 200 mark

Is there an alternative to war with Iraq?

The Marcy Kaptur Controversy

The Mood in Peshawar

Iraq's Future

If Music Be the Food of Love

Ancient Paradigms and New Realities

How a Pakistani Diplomat Engineered the Independence of East Timor

Reflections on Fathers Day

Pakistan Should Recognize Israel

The Return of the Mayflower

Pax Americana Has Its Limits

A Struggle of Heart and Mind in an Ancient Land

A Dress Code, Please!

A Tribute to Edward Said

Straddling the Cultural Fault Lines

The Middle East Quagmire

Is Generarl Boykin a Mouthpiece for President Bush?

The (Ongoing) Rape of My City

Rush Limbaugh is back

The Geneva Accord and the Usual Naysayers

Reflections on a Recently Concluded Journey

Reflections on 2003

Malaria Eradication and Environmental Politics

After All Love Is Not a Many Splendid Thing

Tony Blair and the American Elections

Two Important Happenings on the North West Frontier

The Magic of Cricket

The Perilous Road to Pax America

The Widening Scandal of Iraqi Prisoner's Abuse

A Tribute to the Music Man of Peshawar

Of the Self-Created Cocoons and Muslim Psyche

APPNA Mela 2004

The Riff Raff at our Electronic Doors

A Deeply Polarized and Splintered Country

New Realities and Old Paradigms

Islam's Internal Conflicts

The Never Ending Occupation Misery in Iraq

Irshad Manji’s Controversial Message

Arafat: Passage of an Icon

Of the Mice with Human Brain

An Angry and Resentful Muslim World

Johar Mir: A Tribute

The Ummah's Apathy

Another ‘Abu Gharib’

From Punjab to Fresno: A Fascinating Saga

The Wrath of God that Never Came

Democratic Stirrings in the Middle East

A Pope for All Seasons

Our Diminishing Respect for the Dead

Is it a Light at the End of a Tunnel or a Tunnel at the End of a Light?

Against American Character

The Bedside Rudeness

Unsung and Uncelebrated Heroes of Surgery

Mr. Bush and Ground Realities in Iraq

British Muslims and Self-created Cocoons

We Should Shine a Bright Light on All Those Who Spew Hate

On Being Air-brushed out of One’s Home

When No News Is Good News

The Looming Health Care Crisis in America

Katrina Brought out the Best and the Worst in Us

Attributing Natural Disasters to the Wrath
of God?

Why Don’t Arabs and Muslims Like America?

An Unprecedented Solidarity in the Face of a National Calamity

Political Fissures in Himalayan Landscape

Do Canadians Have It All?

Taking Christmas out of the Christmas Season

Why Is Iran so Defiant of the West?

The Hypocrisy of Cartoons Controversy

Mysteries of Faith

Who Defines What is Sacred and What Is Profane?

What Is an Islamic Dress?

How Powerful is the Israeli Lobby?

New York Wedding Was the Celebration of
Peshawari Culture

Is Afghanistan Turning into Another Iraq?

Religion Can be a Positive Force for Change

On the Road to Khyber Pass

Wahgah Crossing

APPNA: A Unique Organization

Dr. Wafa Sultan & Her 1.2 Bn ‘Psychiatric Patients’

Kis Qayamat Ke Yeh Namey Mere Naam Aate Hai(N)

The Birth Pangs in the Face of an Obstructed Labor

Music: A Common Legacy of Pakistan and India

Where Did the Jihadi Culture Come from?

The Sea Change in Pakistan

We Should Condemn Violence without Any Ifs and Buts

What Was Benedict Hoping to Accomplish?

Magic Latch

Climbing an Impossible Mountain

Pakistan’s President under Mounting Pressure

A Tribute to My Soul Mate

Searching for Real Peshawar

The Anti-Semitism of Jimmy Carter

Palestinian Conflict Deserves a Vigorous Public Debate

Is Resolution of Kashmir Conflict at Hand?

An Assembly of Terrorism Experts

Pakistan Is Plunged into Political Crisis

Helping Turkey Stay Its Westward Course

Violence and Religion: It’s Difficult to Connect the Dots

The Empty Inkwells, the Queen’s Bath and the Pursuit of Happiness: An American Journey - I

The Empty Inkwells, the Queen’s Bath and the Pursuit of Happiness: An American Journey - II

Students, Teachers Share Honor, Debt

The Gulf between the Whites and the Non-whites in Britain

Putting together the Pieces of a Broken Life

The Dishonorable Practice of Honor Killing

Evangelical Groups Make War on Terror
Look Like a Crusade

The Remarkable Journey of Mohsin Ali

Gay Muslims? You Must Be Joking

The Lowly Hyphen Falls Prey to the Computer Age

Journey Difficult after Loved One’s Death

Middle East Success Is Last Chance for Bush Legacy

Mud Cookies at Luxurious Resort would Be just Desert for the Rich

Time to Revamp Antiquated Health Care System

Israel-Palestinian Peace: The Most Spectacular Deception in History

Who Says Pakistanis Are a Cheap Bunch?

At the Gates of Peshawar

‘Custodians’ of Faith Shatter Delicate Harmony

Mehvish Khan’s Guantanamo Diary

Association of Pakistan Muslim Physicians of Pakistani Descent of North America: An Appraisal

In appreciation
Ayub Khan Ommaya: A Polymath

Frail Turkish Democracy Barely Manages to Survive Crisis

Bill Gates Taps Science to Rid World’s Poor of Disease

Muslim Prayers Can't Be a Substitute for Action

An Unfinished Business of the Partition of the Indian Subcontinent

Obama’s Start

Paying Homage to an Unusual Sports Figure  


Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 . All Rights Reserved.