Page 5 - Pakistan Link - November 24, 2023
P. 5

OPINION                                                                                                             PAKISTAN  LINK - NOVEMBER 24, 2023 - P5
            n By Dr Akbar Ahmed        An Evening to Remember                                   even  during  dangerous  and  challeng- Lumpur  inviting  a  leading  Jewish  or
             American University                                                                ing times."                   Christian scholar at the Friday prayer
               Washington, DC                                                                      I  also  acknowledged  the  hurdles  and dedicating a sermon to the scholar.
                                                                                                and challenges Bishop Chane and Rab- It is a great gesture and I hope it will be
            he cathedral is one of the great                                                    bi Lustig have faced in pioneering our  reciprocated by Muslim religious lead-
            houses of worship in America                                                        Abrahamic partnership: "Indeed I have  ers."
       Twith its Gothic towers looming                                                          seen the attacks on the Bishop under   Bishop Chane concluded that eve-
       large over the skyline and rolling hills
                  of the nation’s capital.
                  It is where the Presi-
                  dential Prayer Service
                  is  held  the  morning
                  after  the  inaugura-
                  tion,  bestowing  its
                  blessings upon one of
       the world’s most powerful leaders as
       he enters office. It is where I had the
       honor of representing Islam in serv-
       ing  as  a  pallbearer  for  US  President
       Gerald Ford during his 2007 funeral.
         The cathedral is also where I had the    The significance of a Christian service held at a major cathedral to honor
       privilege of being honored in a special  a Muslim in this period of Islamophobia was not lost on us. About a 1,000
       Sunday  Even  song  prayer  in  February  people from across the nation and the world filled the hallowed pews of the
       2005, dedicated by the Episcopal Bishop  Cathedral - Wikipedia
       of Washington, John Chane, engendered
       by my being named the 2004 Washing- but in acknowledgement of the im- represent the dreamers and visionaries
       ton,  DC  Professor  of  the  Year.  Bishop  portance of building bridges among  of our global community. . . Our times
       Chane, Rabbi Bruce Lustig, the Senior  the faith traditions in an increasingly  together  sharing  food  and  conversa-
       Rabbi  of  Washington’s  largest  syna- discordant world.   tion at a common table with our fami-
       gogue, and I presided over the service.  Rabbi  Lustig  generously  gave  a  lies have filled my heart with joy and
         The significance of a Christian ser- passionate  invocation  titled  "Dr  Ak- hopefulness. It is a hopefulness that the
       vice held at a major cathedral to honor  bar  Ahmed:  A  God  Seeker."  He  told  world, too often divided by those who
       a Muslim in this period of Islamopho- the  congregation:  "As  a  descendant  presume  to  possess  exclusive  claims
       bia was not lost on us. About a 1,000  of  Abraham,  when  others  choose  to  to the true and inerrant knowledge of
       people from across the nation and the  build walls of fear, he chooses to build  the  God  of  all  creation,  will  become
       world filled the hallowed pews of the  bridges of understanding. Akbar does  a world where all can live together in
       Cathedral, including my friend, Jimmy  this not by denying the harsh realities  peace and harmony. For many this may
       Engineer,  who  traveled  all  the  way  of  our  day,  but  by,  in  spite  of  them,  seem a radical statement- for me it is
       from Karachi for the occasion. It was  meeting  others  in  "I-  thou"  encoun- the hope of the world!"  File photos: Muslims participate in a Friday prayer November 14, 2014 at the
       a very emotional evening for all: I saw  ters... Amidst the voices of extremism   Building bridges, I pointed out that  National Cathedral in Washington, DC—AFP
       a BBC journalist wiping tears from her  on  all  sides,  we  are  grateful  that  we  Islam has the highest respect and affec-
       eyes and several Muslims choked with  have  found  another  voice-  it  is  Ak- tion for Biblical figures like Jesus and  the  banner  "Washington’s  first  openly  ning with a message of hope that ac-
       emotion as they told me later that they  bar’s voice; it is calm, it is gentle, it is  Moses.  If  this  connection  was  widely  Jewish and Muslim Bishop." I said, "I  knowledged the importance of services
       could not imagine the holy Qur’an be- filled with wisdom and truth. Indeed,  known, I believed, Western commen- have seen and heard both the Bishop  such as these: "Dialogue is a first begin-
       ing read in the National Cathedral and  Akbar has that courage, to say no to  tators  would  not  talk  about  Muslims  and  the  Senior  Rabbi  stand  up  and  ning of a new journey for this global
       Islam  and  the  holy  Prophet  (pbuh)  hate and violence, and no to fear and  as  "Satan  worshippers"  and  Muslim  speak boldly against the human rights  community."
       cited with respect by a Muslim.  isolation. It is true courage, for even in  leaders would not talk about attacking  violations and loss of civil liberties that   (The  writer  is  an  author,  poet,
         The service was filled with impor- times of personal risk, he continues to  Jews and Christians as a sign of piety.  Muslims often have to endure. This is  filmmaker, playwright, and the Ibn
       tant messages of hope, and while the  say no to injustice and yes to dialogue  "I am confident," I said, "that the great  true faith and friendship."  Khaldun  Chair  of  Islamic  Studies,
       service  was  held  several    years  ago,  and faith in God."  Biblical figures from the time of Abra-  I  concluded  my  remarks  with  a  American University in Washington,
       to this day I fondly recall the warm   Bishop  Chane,  meanwhile,  in  his  ham would commend leaders such as  challenge to the Muslim world: "Imag- D.C. He formerly served as the Paki-
       words both Bishop Chane and Rabbi  sermon  to  close  the  ceremony,  told  Bishop  Chane  and  Rabbi  Lustig  for  ine a reversal of the event: the central  stani High Commissioner to the UK
       Lustig uttered not only in my honor,  the congregation: "Bruce, Akbar and I  recognizing  our  common  humanity  mosque  in  Cairo  or  Lahore  or  Kuala  and Ireland. He tweets @AskAkbar)


           n By Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy                                                              iban  as  Afghanistan’s  lawful  govern- providing TTP terrorists a base. In fact
             Islamabad, Pakistan       Scapegoating the Refugee                                 ment. They committed hideous crimes  the TTP was born in Swat under the
                                                                                                but Pakistan’s high-placed duffers — as  nose of our security forces. Had there
             erded  like  cattle,  over                                                         the inimitable Asma Jahangir famously  been a will, Maulana Fazlullah — aka
             1,700,000   Muslim   refu-                                                         called them — carefully explained away  Mullah Radio — could have been in-
       Hgees — more than twice the                                                              their  savagery.  For  decades  Pakistan  stantly neutralized in 2006-2007.
       number  of  Palestinians  evicted  in                                                    remained the Taliban’s chief champion   To cover up the establishment’s past
                  1948 by Zionist Israel                                                        and loudspeaker to the world.  incompetence and complicity, hapless
                  —  are  presently  be-                                                           When  the  Ashraf  Ghani  govern- refugees  are  now  being  scapegoated.
                  ing expelled from the                                                         ment  fell  in  2021,  there  was  glee  all  They are victims of Pakistan’s bungled
                  Islamic  Republic  of                                                         around.  Then-ISI chief Gen Faiz Ha- foreign  policy  and  its  delusionary
                  Pakistan. A compliant                                                         meed  preened  before  television  cam- pursuit of strategic depth. The days of
                  caretaker government                                                          eras in Kabul as though celebrating his  dollar-fueled  ‘jihad’  being  over,  these
                  wants  all  undocu-                                                           personal victory, while then-PM Imran  penniless people are no longer useful
       mented  Afghans  booted  out  of  the                                                    Khan  famously  proclaimed  Afghans  as  cannon  fodder.  Rich  Afghans,  of
       country.                                                                                 had “broken the shackles of slavery”.  course, may stay.
         Taking this a step further, the Balo-                                                     Things  have  changed  dramatically   Had  Pakistan  ever  been  serious
       chistan caretaker information minister                                                   since then and we know exactly why.  about wanting to destroy TTP’s ideo-
       declared earlier this week that, in line                                                 After a victory, the force of fanaticism  logically  charged  terrorism,  it  would
       with the state’s decision, even those Af- To cover up the establishment’s past incompetence and complicity, hapless   does not diminish — it grows. Backed  have looked for places where the call to
       ghans with legal documents would be  refugees are now being scapegoated. They are victims of Pakistan’s bungled   by the government in Kabul, TTP now  ‘jihad’ is loud and strident.
       expelled. Who runs the state is clear.  foreign policy and its delusionary pursuit of strategic depth. The days of   savagely  attacks  Pakistan’s  army  and   All  across  the  Muslim  world  the
         Once  these  unfortunates  cross  the  dollar-fueled ‘jihad’ being over, these penniless people are no longer useful   police almost daily.  mullah  has  been  tamed  by  the  state.
       Torkham  border,  hell  awaits  them.  as cannon fodder. Rich Afghans, of course, may stay – Photo BBC  Worried Pakistani rulers tried per- Yet  there’s  little  chance  that  Pakistani
       Large  numbers  have  never  visited,                                                    suading  Afghanistan’s  rulers  to  de- madrassas  preaching  violence  will  be
       much less known, the famine-stricken  only  Rs50,000  per  family  could  be  murderous and misogynist militia that  nounce  these  terrorist  acts  but  met  investigated.  Maulana  Abdul  Aziz,
       land  to  which  they  allegedly  belong.  carried  in  cash,  and  forbade  evictees  hates  all  forms  of  modernity  except  a  brick  wall.  Why  expect  otherwise?  leader  of  the  Lal  Masjid  insurrection
       Hundreds of thousands were born on  from taking along their livestock. Who  its guns. No girl may go to school, no  Both  the  TTP  and  Afghan  Taliban  that killed well over 200, supports the
       Pakistani soil but could never acquire  could be more heartless? Zionists?  woman  may  work,  music  and  art  are  carry the same mindset and have the  TTP but struts around Islamabad with
       documents.                      The story of loss and displacement  forbidden, limb-chopping and stoning  same goals.  armed escort.
         Pakistani  authorities  gave  but  30  doesn’t end here. After enduring extor- to death are back in vogue.  Although  many  Afghans  fled  to   Those who ordered the sudden de-
       short  days  to  sell  off  possessions  ac- tion by Pakistani border guards, they   In  1996,  Pakistan  was  the  first  of  Pakistan after the 2021 Taliban victory,  portations claim to defend Pakistan’s
       quired  over  a  lifetime,  decreed  that  will enter a country run by a primitive,  three  countries  to  recognize  the  Tal- they are now being falsely accused of   (Continued on page 23)
                                                                        www.Pakistanlink.com
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10