By Dr. Nayyer Ali

February 01, 2008

Benazir’s Tragedy

The violent end of the turbulent life of Benazir Bhutto brought to a close a remarkable chapter in the history of Pakistan. Throughout her life Benazir was a deeply confused Pakistani, unsure of what she wanted or how to get it, but consumed with ambition, and ultimately undone by her own bad choices.
Her journey  to political prominence was sourced in her family,  as the daughter of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, came to prominence as a civilian member of the inner  cabinet of General Ayub Khan in the 1960’s.  Her father used his gifts of rhetoric and demagoguery to become the Prime Minister of Pakistan in 1971 as head of the socialist and secular Pakistan People’s Party.  In fact, her father had lost the 1970 election, but instead of accepting defeat, he forced a civil war that dismembered the country and killed hundreds of thousands of East Pakistanis in a futile attempt to prevent secession.

ZAB then took power in West Pakistan, and ruled as a dictator, creating his own secret police and rigging elections.  When ZAB lost popularity due to his incompetence and mismanagement  and the inevitable chaos of widespread nationalization of industry, the army took advantage and overthrew him.  He was hung after being convicted of murder by a Supreme Court under the control of General Zia, the new ruler.
Benazir, along with her two brothers, now inherited their father’s legacy and the People’s Party.  Benazir’s older brother died in Paris in the 1980’s, and was likely murdered.  Benazir returned to  Pakistan in 1986 to challenge Zia, and came to power as Prime Minister at the age of 36 in 1988.  Her first government lasted till 1990,  then she got another turn in the PM office from 1994-1996. Unfortunately,  while Benazir was hugely ambitious when it came to getting power, she had no idea what she wanted to do with it.  
Many educated Pakistanis, and many Westerners, were initially fooled by her background as the polished, English-speaking graduate of Harvard and Oxford. This woman certainly was the right person to lead Pakistan towards development and gender equality. She would bring modern sensibilities and commitment to democracy and rule of law to Pakistan.  And she would be a great example to women in Pakistan and across the Muslim world.
But in reality, Benazir was not the modern educated and sophisticated person she could so easily get Americans to believe she was.  Instead she was a throwback to the feudal landlord elites that have always dominated Pakistani politics.  The landlord mentality is one that sees the purpose of government the maintenance and expansion of their personal privilege and power. This was in fact  what the Bhutto governments were all about. She never passed a single piece of legislation in her time in power.  There was never any attempt to undo the horrible Hudood and Blasphemy Laws that Zia had imposed.  The status of women was not addressed in any way.  Education got no significant boost as Bhutto refused to make it a national priority, preferring to keep the country as illiterate as possible, and constantly pleading poverty as her excuse for why she did nothing (except when forced to on one occasion by the IMF).
Instead of fashioning a new and modern economic policy, Bhutto turned every government ministry and state-owned corporation into the feudal playthings of her supporters.  Her husband single-handedly essentially destroyed PIA.  And the scale of corruption was so massive that Pakistan was declared the second-most corrupt nation on the planet by Transparency International. Bhutto’s legacy was terrible indeed.
But Bhutto did two other things to the nation for which she cannot be  forgiven.  First was the discrediting of democracy that her misrule, combined with Nawaz Sharif’s, achieved.  It was the culmination of 10 years  of pathetic kleptocracy that paved the way for the bloodless Musharraf coup.  A coup that was greeted with joy by Benazir’s party, if we recall our history.
The other was her attempt to be a bit too clever in 1995, when she granted Fazlur Rahman, the head of the Islamist JUI party, to oversee Afghan policy.  Rahman then used the madrassahs  run by the JUI for the Afghan refugees to become the main recruiting ground for a  new Afghan movement known as the “Taliban”, and decided to throw Pakistan’s support to this movement as it swept over Afghanistan.  This decision by Bhutto, to support the expansion of power for the most religiously radical groups laid the basis for the rise of Baitullah Mehsud, a leader of the Pakistani Taliban, and the person most likely responsible for Benazir’s death. In fact, policy choices made by Benazir, which were totally inconsistent with a person who truly valued religious tolerance, human freedom, and democracy, created the Taliban, Al-Qaeda’s Afghan rebirth, 9/11, and ultimately Benazir’s own assassination. Terribly ironic, and an object lesson for us all.  Comments can reach me at



Deflating Japan

Bush’s Axis of Evil

Speaking to Non-Muslims

If Arafat Were Jinnah

The Shape of Things to Come

South Asia Expert Calls for Negotiations on Kashmir

Kashmir After the Cold War

Kashmir Quagmire: How It Started

Kashmir: Where We’ve Been

Make Way for the Euro

Will there Be a Muslim Palestine?

Careful, Careful

Our Growing Community

Pakistan’s Golden Opportunity

Musharraf’s Reform Plans

Pakistan’s Afghan Dilemma

Humanity on the Move

Strategies of America, Pakistan and Benazir

Winners and Losers

America’s Strategy Defang the Fundamentalists

The Noose Tightens

Pakistan in America

Musharraf’s Moment

A Sad Day for America, A Sad Day for Islam

Repeal the Blasphemy Law

Bush’s Stem Cell Compromise

The Depressing Stock Market

An Evening on Human Development

“Benazir” Takes Over in Indonesia

Race Riots in Britain

Global Warming or Just Hot Air?

Milosevic on Trial

Russia’s Collapse

Economic Recovery in Pakistan?

President Khatami’s Re-election

Lifting Sanctions on Pakistan

Israel’s Moral Burden

A Break in the Logjam?

The Second American Century

Pakistan’s Constitution

Dr. Lodhi in Los Angeles

Literacy: The Road Forward

Why Yusuf Can't Read

Literacy: The Glass is Half Full

Blowing Up Buddha

A Truth and Reconciliation Commission for Pakistan

Did You See the Moon?

Cornrows, Ali Khan, and Culture

Will the Children Go To Harvard?

Muslim Political Progress

Information Technology Gets A Boost

Sand and Oil

On Lieberman

Pakistan Builds A Tank

Kashmir in the Nuclear Age

Full Speed Ahead on Privatization

A Muslim France?

Too Much Food

Watching the Election Why Are We Hollywood’s Villains?

A Tyrant Falls

Taliban Victorious

The Walking Whale of Pakistan
The Joy of Air Travel?

The Amazing American Economy
Arafat and Jerusalem

Names For The Children

Population: Too Many or Too Few?

It Does Matter

Aziz Goes For Growth

The Military Government's First Budget

L'Affaire Salam

End Sanctions on Iraq

Third World Democracy

Light Weapons Trade on the Rise

Iran Reforms

Back to the Future

The Saudis and OPEC Mature

How Can We Help Pakistan Develop?

Report Card on Musharraf

IMF Vs Pakistan

A Candid Discussion on Foreign Policy Issues

A Sad Tale of Missed Opportunities

Cold War In Kashmir

Whither Afghanistan?

National Security and Literacy

Pakistan Votes

The People Win

What is an Islamist?

Selling the Crown Jewels

Still Not Government

One Year After the Taliban

Benazir's Folly

Iraq and Oil

Saddam and Iraq - I

Saddam and Iraq - 2

Muslim Democracy

Zakat and Capitalism

Zakat and Capitalism - 2

The Economy Picks Up

The American Military: Power without Limit?

Good Foreign Policy is Good Anti-Terrorism Policy

The Arrest of Khalid Shaikh Mohammad

Bush Takes a Gamble

Bush Attacks

Besieging Baghdad

Darkness in Saddam's Bunker

Piccadilly It Aint Qissa Khani Is Still Qissa Kahani

Ed Asner and Afghanistan's Progress

Bush Delivers a Roadmap

Liberation or Imperialism

The Roadmap

Economic Rebound

Musharraf in Los Angeles

Economic Growth will lead to Democracy

Trapped by Myths and Fantasies

The Surge in Karachi Stocks

Bush's Busted Budget

America's Broken Healthcare

Time to Buy Stocks?

Islam, the State, and Human Rights

30 Years after the Oil Shock

The Future of Oil Wealth

Pakistan, India and Human Development

Pakistan's Eid Present

Iraq, Democracy and Islam

The End of Saddam Hussein

Three Wins for Pakistan

The Islamabad Declaration

Kerry's Big Wins

Repeal Hudood and Blasphemy

Bush's Growing Vulnerability

What Has Aziz Done?

Bits and Pieces

The Growth of India

Chaos in Iraq

Bush Caves in to Sharon

Abuse at Abu Ghraib

Too Harsh, Musharraf

The BJP Loses

What Do the Jihadis Want?

The Pak Economy: Bigger than We Think

Is America Richer than Europe?

Prime Minister Aziz

Unbundling WAPDA

Musharraf's Uniform

Chess Game in Kashmir

Three States, Three Debates

What's Wrong with the Democrats?

Can Elections Bring Peace to Iraq?

Elections in Iraq

Can Generals Yield to Democrats?

IMF Give Pakistan an “A”

Improve Higher Education in Pakistan

A Framework for Reconciliation

Iraq’s Elections By

Privatizing Power

Bullish in Karachi

Palestinians Should Abandon Suicide Bombings

The F-16’s

Bush’s Social Security Plan

Growth and Investment

Patronage Versus Policy

Aziz, the PML, and 2007

Are We Running out of Oil?

Purchasing Power

Economic Progress

Social Progress

PTCL and the Privatization Roller-coaster

Bombing in Britain

The Ummah is Not a Tribe

Is the US Oppressing the Muslims?

Is Iraq Dissolving?

Sharon Retreats

Pakistan and Israel

The Earthquake

The Other Earthquakes

The Battle for the Supreme Court

Pakistan’s Physician Exports

Beginning of the End in Palestine

Intelligent Design and Other Religious Beliefs

Shifting Populations in South Asia

Sharon’s Stroke

Building Dams

Hamas in Charge

Free Elections in 2007

Muslim Perspectives on Zionism

Iraq Falls Apart

Big Successes in Privatization

Iran’s Nuclear Ambitions

Global Warming

Dennis Ross on the Middle East

What Makes an Islamic State?

The Iraq War

Strong Growth, Falling Poverty

Buffett and His Billions

Why Peace Is Elusive in the Middle East

How Poor is Poor?

How Poor is Poor?
Pakistan’s Growth Moment

Declare a Palestinian State

The London Bomb Plot

Who Won the Lebanon War?

Iran, Israel, and the Bomb

The Pope’s Speech

Democrats Win!

The Republicans Lick Their Wounds

Finally, Some Enlightened Moderation

The Error in the War on Terror

Economic Challenges for Pakistan

Reshaping the Middle East - Part 1

Reshaping the Middle East - Part Two

The Surge to Defeat

Whither Palestinians?

Pakistan and Afghanistan

Blind to the Future?

Musharraf Goes Too Far

Letter from Lahore

Can Musharraf Escape His Own Trap?

Will Healthcare Swallow the Economy?

Israel’s Surprise Offer

The Economy Surges Again

Al Gore Should Run

Pakistan’s Arms Industry

Any Exit from Iraq?

Deal, No Deal, or Many Deals

Nawaz Comes and Goes

Will Musharraf Wriggle Through?

Can We Stop Global Warming?

Bush’s Sputtering “War on Terror” Loses Again

Mental Health at Guantanamo Bay

What a Mess!

Will Musharraf’s Errors Prove Fatal?

How About Some Good News?

Anyone but Nawaz

China, India, and Pakistan: Whose Citizens Live Best?

Electing the Next President

Editor: Akhtar M. Faruqui
© 2004 . All Rights Reserved.