By Dr. Nayyer Ali
September 20, 2019
Britain and Brexit
By Nayyer Ali MD
Ever since a narrow win for Leave in the Brexit referendum in 2016, British governance has been paralyzed by the problem of how to actually achieve Brexit. Originally, the idea was that Britain would leave the European Union after a detailed agreement was signed by both sides and that ensured there was smooth change to a new system.
During the referendum campaign, it was never clearly spelled out what that new system would look like. Would Britain still be in the European free trade area? What would be the rules governing immigration between the two sides and the movement of travelers? And most importantly, what would be done with Northern Ireland, where decades of Catholic/Protestant strife was quelled in 1998 under the Good Friday Agreement? That agreement, which included not just groups within Northern Ireland (which is part of the UK), but also included the British and Irish governments, removed the border controls between Ireland and Northern Ireland.
Under Brexit, if Britain no longer allowed the free movement of goods and people between the UK and the EU, then a hard border with the usual customs and immigration control would have to be set up again. Such an action would unravel the Good Friday Agreement and possible plunge Northern Ireland back into violence and unrest.
The Conservative Prime Minister for the last three years, Theresa May, did negotiate a final agreement with the EU, one in which trade links would be maintained and the Good Friday Agreement would not be threatened. But a small faction of hardliners in her own party voted that down repeatedly because it left Britain too closely aligned with the EU. May eventually gave up and resigned last month, and Boris Johnson, a hard line Brexiteer, became Prime Minister.
Johnson claims that he can get a better deal from the EU if he threatens to leave without an agreement by October 31, a “crashing out” of the EU that would bring possible economic chaos to Britain. But the Labor and Liberal Democrats in opposition teamed up with enough moderate Conservative MPs to block that and pass a law preventing Johnson from crashing out. He is legally required now to go to the EU and request another 90-day extension on Brexit.
So, where does Boris Johnson go from here? One option is for him to defy the law and simply do nothing. Without a formal request from London, the EU cannot grant an extension on its own, and while the Parliament passed the law, the Prime Minister has to actually follow it. Would Johnson risk possible prison or loss of power to carry out a hard Brexit on October 31? I doubt that. But Johnson likely has another strategy in mind.
Johnson will comply with this law for now. But he will then call a new election for November. His goal will be to win a clear victory and have the mandate then to pursue a hard Brexit. The voters in Britain are split. In a mirror of American politics, Brexit is supported by older, White, less educated, rural voters. Remain is supported by urban, younger, educated, and more diverse voters. The vote in 2016 was very close. A revote on Brexit would be hard to predict but would likely result in an overturning of the original referendum. The opposition wants a revote on any final agreement to either carry it out or cancel Brexit. The Leave camp at this point wants a hard Brexit and to leave the EU with no agreement, regardless of the consequences.
Would Brexit really be a catastrophe? There would certainly be disruption to trade and industry, and to the flow of workers between the EU and Britain. But in the long run these issues would be worked out. Britain did fine even when it was not part of the EU. Leaving would be an economic hit, but not a disaster.
Where Brexit would cause major problems for Britain is internally. After a hard Brexit, the situation in Northern Ireland could become very difficult again. Even more importantly, the Scots are dead set against leaving the EU. Scotland narrowly defeated an independence referendum in 2014, after Brexit, the Scots would likely vote to leave the UK and rejoin the EU as a new nation.
Boris Johnson is calculating that he can win a new election in November. The Labor leader, Jeremy Corbyn, is an extreme left-winger who frightens a lot of middle-class Britons, giving the Conservatives an election advantage. In addition, with the British system of first past the post, Johnson thinks he can consolidate the Leave voters behind his party, while the Remain voters will split between Labor, Liberal Democrats, and the Scottish National Party (in Scotland of course). As such, he could win a big Parliamentary majority even if he only gets 40-45% of the total vote. But even if he does succeed at that, history will not look at him kindly if the result is the political collapse of the UK.
|
PREVIOUSLY
Three States, Three Debates
What's
Wrong with the Democrats?
Can
Elections Bring Peace to Iraq?
Elections
in Iraq
Can
Generals Yield to Democrats?
IMF
Give Pakistan an “A”
Improve
Higher Education in Pakistan
A
Framework for Reconciliation
Iraq’s
Elections By
Privatizing
Power
Bullish
in Karachi
Palestinians
Should Abandon Suicide Bombings
The
F-16’s
Bush’s
Social Security Plan
Growth
and Investment
Patronage
Versus Policy
Aziz,
the PML, and 2007
Are
We Running out of Oil?
Purchasing
Power
Economic
Progress
Social
Progress
PTCL
and the Privatization Roller-coaster
Bombing
in Britain
The
Ummah is Not a Tribe
Is
the US Oppressing the Muslims?
Is
Iraq Dissolving?
Sharon
Retreats
Pakistan
and Israel
The
Earthquake
The
Other Earthquakes
The
Battle for the Supreme Court
Pakistan’s
Physician Exports
Beginning
of the End in Palestine
Intelligent
Design and Other Religious Beliefs
Shifting
Populations in South Asia
Sharon’s
Stroke
Building
Dams
Hamas
in Charge
Free
Elections in 2007
Muslim
Perspectives on Zionism
Iraq
Falls Apart
Big
Successes in Privatization
Iran’s
Nuclear Ambitions
Global
Warming
Dennis
Ross on the Middle East
What
Makes an Islamic State?
The
Iraq War
Strong
Growth, Falling Poverty
Buffett
and His Billions
Why
Peace Is Elusive in the Middle East
How
Poor is Poor?
How
Poor is Poor?
Pakistan’s Growth Moment
Declare
a Palestinian State
The
London Bomb Plot
Who
Won the Lebanon War?
Iran,
Israel, and the Bomb
The
Pope’s Speech
Democrats
Win!
The
Republicans Lick Their Wounds
Finally,
Some Enlightened Moderation
The
Error in the War on Terror
Economic
Challenges for Pakistan
Reshaping
the Middle East - Part 1
Reshaping
the Middle East - Part Two
The
Surge to Defeat
Whither
Palestinians?
Pakistan
and Afghanistan
Blind
to the Future?
Musharraf
Goes Too Far
Letter
from Lahore
Can
Musharraf Escape His Own Trap?
Will
Healthcare Swallow the Economy?
Israel’s
Surprise Offer
The
Economy Surges Again
Al
Gore Should Run
Pakistan’s
Arms Industry
Any
Exit from Iraq?
Deal,
No Deal, or Many Deals
Nawaz
Comes and Goes
Will
Musharraf Wriggle Through?
Can
We Stop Global Warming?
Bush’s
Sputtering “War on Terror” Loses Again
Mental
Health at Guantanamo Bay
What
a Mess!
Will Musharraf’s
Errors Prove Fatal?
How About Some Good News?
Anyone but Nawaz
China, India, and Pakistan: Whose Citizens Live Best?
Electing the Next President
Benazir’s Tragedy
Pakistan Election
Democracy and Pakistan
False Hopes in Palestine
Dinner with Shaukat Aziz
How Real Were Aziz’s Reforms?
The State of Pakistan
A Real Debate on Iraq
Stop Negotiating
Severe Challenges Face Pakistan’s Economy
Mindless Obsession with Musharraf
After Musharraf, More Musharraf?
Can Obama Do It?
Pakistan’s Poverty Profile
Economic Crisis in Pakistan
Can Obama Beat McCain?
Was the Aziz Boom a Mirage?
Pakistan’s Presidency
The Failed Presidency of George W. Bush
McCain Is Not Finished
The Economic Meltdown
A Year after the Annapolis Peace Conference
The Significance of Obama’s Win
Pakistan’s Economic Challenge
New Finds in Qur’anic History
The Assault on Gaza
Is a Trillion Dollar Stimulus Really Needed?
Bush’s Economic Legacy
How Big a Problem is Global Warming?
The Collapse of Oil Prices
Barack and the Banks
Pakistan Surrenders to the Taliban
The Collapse of the Republicans
Will Debt Defeat Obama?
Will Debt Defeat Obama?
The Torture Debate
Israel and Iran: Tyrants Cling to Power
Healthcare Reform
Is Israel Held to A Higher Standard?
Pak Economy Needs Growth
How to Really Control Health Care Costs
Do Not Attack Iran
Obama Confronts Failure in Afghanistan
Why Does the Islamic World Under-perform?
Final Chance for Palestine?
What Killed the Pak Economy in 2008?
Should Obama Fight Global Warming?
Obama’s Good Start
The Twisted Logic of the Extremists
Should France Ban the Burqa?
Slow Progress in Pakistan
Palestinians Resume Negotiations
The Farce of Islamic Creationism
Obama’s Secret Plan to Raise Taxes
Democratic Steps in Pakistan
Faisal Shahzad and the Taliban
Can Obama Win in Afghanistan?
The Meaning of Israeli Piracy
Annual Economic Survey of Pakistan
Nostalgia for Musharraf
No Good Choices for Netanyahu
The Attacks on Islam
The Trends in American Politics
Immigration Reshaping US and Europe
Pointless Peace Talks with Netanyahu
Another Episode of Military Rule?
Pakistan ’s Misguided Afghan Strategy
The Middle East in Wikileaks
Brazil Recognizes Palestine
Obama’s Tax Deal
Republicans, Tax Cuts, and Bad Math
Pakistan in Chaos
The Tunisian Revolution
The Arabs and Democracy
The Palestinians and Peace
The Arab Spring Continues
Bin Laden is Dead
Can We Go Back to Normal?
Obama and the 1967 Borders for Palestine
Was Pakistan Helping bin Laden?
Can the American Economy Be Fixed?
Pakistan’s Weak Economy
The Fall of Gadhafi
America Has a Jobs Crisis, Not a Debt Crisis
Ten Years after 9/11
The State of Palestine
The Failure of Pakistan’s Afghan Policy
The Failure of Pakistan’s Afghan Policy
Will Obama Win or Lose in 2012?
The Meaning of ‘Occupy Wall Street’
100,000 Rally for Imran Khan
Don’t Worry, America Is Not Italy
The Failure of Pakistan’s Afghan Policy
Newt Invents Palestine
Operation Iraqi Freedom Ends
Obama's Many Paths to Victory
Islam’s Not So Bloody Borders
Can We Stop Global Warming?
The Supreme Court Worries about Broccoli
The Coming Republican Meltdown
The Endless Republican Depression
The Demise of the Euro
Mending US-Pakistan Relations
Acid Throwers in Pakistan
Bloodbath in Syria
Obama Wins Big on Health Care
Romney, Obama, Virginia and Iowa
1.6 Billion Muslims
A White House Iftar
Transforming Saudi Arabia
A Romney Loss Will Crush the Republicans
The Historical Roots of Modern Jihad
Obama Flops in First Debate
Obama and Romney Go Down to the Wire
The End of the Southern Strategy
Occupation Is the Problem
The Republicans Have a Problem with White People
Obama Halves the Deficit
Has the Arab Spring Failed?
Ten Years Ago Bush Destroyed Iraq and His Presidency
How Much Longer for Assad?
Terror in Boston
The Economy Comes Back
Third Chance for Nawaz Sharif
Third Chance for Nawaz Sharif
Immigration Reform Moves Forward
The Fall of the Muslim Brotherhood
The Receding Threat of Global Warming
Still Seeking a Palestinian State
The Republicans' Desperate Shutdown
Was Thomas Jefferson A Muslim?
Time to Raise the Minimum Wage
I nequality and Islam
Israel and Palestine
How Poor is Pakistan?
The Collapse of Iraq
Bill Maher’s Islamophobia
Obama’s Puzzling Unpopularity
Obama’s Nuclear Weapon
Defeating ISIS
Pakistan Must Return to the Vision of Jinnah
Maher Hathout: A Tribute
I Am Not Charlie
Obama Strikes a Deal with Iran
Assad Barely Hangs On
China Invests in Pakistan
The Future of Islam
Obama Makes a Deal with Iran
Obama Fights Global Warming
Pakistan Should Not Fear
Directorate S and Afghanistan
Liberals Always Win
Fifteen Years Later in Iraq
The End of War
Trump Quits Iran Deal
Palestine Continues to Bleed
Pakistan Goes to the Polls in July
National Debt and Entitlements
Muslims Must Reject Anti-Semitism
Israel Votes for Discrimination
Naya Pakistan
We Are All Sayyid
The Great President Carter
Rising Education in Pakistan
The Democratic Agenda
A Blue Wave
Medicare for All
We’re Winning on Climate Change
A Shrinking Planet
Ilhan Omar, Israel, and Apartheid
The Democrats Are All the Same
The IMF Deal
Fears of a Sixth Extinction
Trump’s Reelection
Trump and the Taliban
The Falling Rupee is Working
|
